All stories

Three years as a trans man, then home from college

Female · Desisted379
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I'm a detransitioned woman (she/they) who socially lived as a trans man for about three years, from age sixteen until I desisted at nineteen in 2021 without ever medically transitioning. I came to question everything rapidly while home from college, realizing I was comfortable as a tomboyish, gender-nonconforming girl and that my dysphoria may have been rooted in bullying, never feeling pretty, religious/misogynistic environments, and gifted-girl invisibility. I told all my friends in June 2021 and received support, and I now feel more confident in my womanhood than I did during transition. I regret coming out and the years lost, but not my short hair, men's clothes, or masculine expression. I have diagnosed anxiety, suspect I may be autistic but have never been screened, and have not come out to my deeply anti-trans parents about desisting.

Full story

I began questioning my gender at fourteen, floating through genderfluid, non-binary, and demiboy labels while keeping 'transgender boy' locked away. I came out to myself as a trans man at sixteen and socially transitioned over the following years, going by a male name and he/him pronouns, binding my chest, cutting my hair short, and dressing masculinely. I was stealth at my first college, lived on the men's floor of my dorm, and dated as a boy. I never pursued hormones or surgery, but I wanted testosterone, top surgery, a beard, and a deep voice. I'm bisexual and was always open about that. My parents are extremely anti-trans — they called me slurs, forbade me from cutting my hair until I turned eighteen, and my brother called me a slur — so I never came out to them as trans; I knew they would disown me. I was raised Pentecostal and attended a Southern Baptist private school my whole life, where I was closeted about both my bisexuality and later my trans identification; I also went through a homophobic phase in that environment. I was a gifted student (all As, honors, first year of college completed in high school, scholarships) and noticed that when I presented as female, my ambition to be a writer was dismissed or redirected, while as a man in class I was called 'brilliant' and 'a hard worker.' I was bullied growing up for my looks — thick curly hair, darker complexion, taller and more muscular build — in a very whitewashed school where I stood out. I have diagnosed anxiety. I also suspect I might be on the autism spectrum but have never been screened; my mom is a therapist who works with autistic children. I met a lot of trans people through anime fandom online and in college, and I'm Gen-Z. Around May 2021, home from college and having transferred to a school closer to my hometown, I started questioning rapidly. I realized I no longer minded being seen as a tomboyish girl, and I began imagining myself in sundresses and makeup. I wondered whether my dysphoria was really body dysmorphia or an attempt to gain control over the masculinity I disliked about myself, shaped by never having felt pretty. Within days I concluded I was not trans and began desisting. I posted about regretting ever coming out — angry at myself for 'wasting a year' of college living as a man and for the two prior years closeted and isolated online with trans people, feeling like an outcast. I was terrified of telling friends, fearing judgment, but on June 5, 2021 I told all my friends I was going back to female, using my birthname and she/they pronouns. I received love from friends, especially longtime ones, and some no reaction at all. I now describe myself as a gender-nonconforming woman: she for my womanhood, they for my androgynous GNC expression. I don't regret cutting my hair, buying men's clothes, or owning my masculinity — I just wish I'd had the courage to do so without identifying as trans. I feel more confident now than before or during my transition, and I've said 'the real performance was trying to be male.' I have not discussed detransition with my parents. I remain active in online political discussion as a political science major and have argued that the detrans community should not be silenced by either right-wing groups or certain trans activists.