All stories

Years of estrogen, still using he/him

Male · Detransitioned-28
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born male and took estrogen for years while identifying as MtF, but I always used he/him because I saw myself as a man. I now say I don't think trans identities exist, that a man is an adult human male, and that presentation is a construct while sex is not. Therapy has helped me accept myself, and I consider HRT effects largely reversible. I'm critical of medical transition for others, especially of testosterone for females, and I advocate for people to just express themselves without hormones.

Full story

I was born male and I've always considered myself a man — to me a man is simply an adult human male, not a hormone level or a clothing style. Even when I identified as MtF, I used he/him pronouns because I never saw the point of changing them; I'm biologically male and I knew it. I took estrogen for years. It improved my skin and made me look younger, and I actually lost weight on it rather than gaining, which surprised people who warned me otherwise. I have ADD and take prescribed Adderall, which also helps with weight loss. I kept going to the gym actively the whole time and continued to gain muscle mass even on estrogen, so I don't buy the idea that you can't build muscle on E — you can. I also don't think trans identities really exist. A man is an adult human male, not a hormone level or clothing style. My advice to people questioning is just to be yourself as a person and not worry about what your gender is — if you want to dress a certain way, do that; you don't need to mess with hormones to look how you want. Presentation is a construct, sex is not. Every person has masculine and feminine traits; being a man doesn't mean being masculine, and being a woman doesn't mean being feminine. I hate terms like 'trans masc' and 'trans fem' because they create new, incorrect boxes. Even when I was presenting more femininely, there was nothing I was doing that wasn't being a man — I was still very masculine, more so than most FtM people. I was never trans fem. Taking artificial hormones will never make you the same as the opposite sex, and often pushes you into a new sub-minority of your own sex. There is no surgery that gives a female actual male parts — just a bad facsimile with a heck of a lot of scarring. For someone born female, testosterone is especially bad: it can cause depression, suicidal thoughts, periods, weight gain, an awful-sounding voice, subpar facial hair, and reduced lifespan. Estrogen, by contrast, makes people look younger, prevents baldness, and lets people feel emotions. I've told women that if actual males can pass, they have a far better chance — they don't have a male brow bone or male jawline, so they should just let the estrogen do its thing. Therapy has helped me accept myself. Fortunately for me, HRT is very reversible. I try to live by the idea that you can dress and act however you want regardless of your sex — wear a suit if you like; for females it's socially acceptable anyway, so there's less societal pushback.