All stories

A cis man who found kinship among detransitioners

Male · Desisted456
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned-community participant who has never transitioned: I identify as a man, describe myself as bi and fluid, and have processed childhood attachment trauma in therapy. I came to these spaces after hating myself in circles that blamed everything on being a cis white straight male, and I now advocate for deep introspection before transition and criticize the "egg" concept. I am critical of transition being presented as the only path to peace, while remaining supportive of individuals' own journeys. I have no medical interventions of my own and no reported suicidal ideation or self-harm. I remain active as a supportive voice, offering direct help to people currently detransitioning.

Full story

I have been active in detrans spaces for years, mostly as a supportive voice for others, and through that I have shared pieces of my own story. I am a man — I describe myself as a cis white straight male by all appearances, and elsewhere as a 37m — and I have never transitioned; I come to this community as someone who has wrestled with gender, sexuality, and self-acceptance from the outside. I grew up with attachment challenges from childhood. My mother was my primary caretaker, and she had emotional outbursts that scared me during formative periods. That conflict — being drawn to women because they make me feel safe, while also finding them frightening — created what I have called a pretty disorganized relationship with women, and with gender as well. I still consider myself to be bi and fluid because certain aspects of my personality were parked in a "girl" part where they could be safe because "boys don't do that". Integrating all of these different parts into "me" where they can live safely has helped me immensely. At one point I found myself hating what I was because I spent too much time in circles of people who had come to blame "wrongness" on basically everything I was — by all appearances a cis white straight male. It didn't matter that I was "one of the good ones"; there was always an undertone of the "original sin" of being a man. That experience shaped my sympathy for people who feel pushed toward transition by their environment. I have processed a huge amount of big and little traumas in therapy, and I believe others can too. I am a singer, and I have used that to encourage others whose voices have changed. I work in engineering — I've joked about fellow engineers uniting — and I try to live by accepting my body as it is configured: I run to keep my body strong and in the shape I like, I do it for myself, and I accept myself as a bigger, less delicate, and gentle-hearted male body. I wear skirts sometimes when I feel like it. I have nerdy hobbies and stereotypical ones, and I don't care if others think they're weird. In relationships, I have been poly and was long before any kind of gender or orientation questioning. I have no issues with monogamy or any other structure. I have attachment challenges that make me anxious around attraction, and I have noted that I still get nervous any time there's a spark of attraction with women. I have never undergone hormones or surgery myself, so there are no medical interventions or complications in my own story. What I bring to this community is the perspective of someone who has done a lot of introspection about gender without transitioning, and who believes people should be challenged to look for peace with their bodies in themselves first before jumping straight to transitioning, because transitioning adds a whole pile of complicating factors. I have been critical of the "egg" concept, saying it creates a perverse incentive to "crack an egg" for the score rather than really challenging the person to do the introspection needed to determine if they're trans, or if dysmorphia has another cause. I have been a steady defender of this community against outside criticism — arguing it doesn't meet any criteria of a cult, pushing back on people who come in to make low-effort digs at detrans posters, and insisting it is a place where detrans people can air raw feelings. I have also defended posters here who were accused of being trans-exclusionary, arguing they were simply processing painful feelings. I have been critical of people who continue to act with stereotypical "male" condescension and lack of empathy toward women, saying they are failing at feminism no matter what their identity is. I have offered direct support to people in crisis here, telling one person to finish detransitioning and that they are welcome at my table any time, with a home-cooked meal and a seat by the fire on the porch, and giving them my DMs. I continue to identify as I always have — a man, bi and fluid in orientation — and I am at peace with that.