All stories

Three years on estrogen, then quitting cold turkey

Male · Detransitioned29
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned man who lived as a trans woman for several years, took estrogen for about three years, and quit cold turkey roughly four years ago. I transitioned, in my own words, out of "insecure homosexual reasons" rather than AGP, and dealing with my FOMO about passing was my ticket out of obsessing over transition. Getting my breast tissue surgically removed was key to rebuilding confidence in my identity as a man, though I live with irreversible skin-texture changes from estrogen. I now feel confident and mature, and I'm critical of how transition is marketed, especially to youth and around passing.

Full story

I was born male and identified as trans for several years. I started hormone replacement therapy and stayed on it for about three years before stopping cold turkey — no tapering, no weaning off. I've now been off HRT for roughly four years. Looking back, I don't think AGP was my motive. I tell people I transitioned for "insecure homosexual reasons" — what I describe as the flip side of the coin from AGP. I was dealing with shame and insecurity around being gay, and that pushed me toward transition rather than any autogynephilic fantasy. One of the biggest things I've had to work through is FOMO — fear of missing out. I genuinely believe FOMO is a huge driver of what I call "trans hysteria": the obsessive belief that if you'd just started younger, at 15 instead of 18 or 20 instead of 25, you'd pass. I call that bullshit. Dealing with my own FOMO was, in my words, my ticket out of obsessing about trans stuff. I've tried to explain to others that the vast majority of people have zero chance of consistently passing after puberty, and that bones and the cranial vault are largely set by age 5-6, long before anyone is thinking about transition. I also had to reckon with the physical reality of what estrogen does permanently. I tell people not to underestimate it: estrogen permanently changes skin texture and breast tissue development. Those changes don't fully reverse. Even now, with what I describe as a strongly masculine facial structure, people still tell me I look like a little kid because my skin stayed bouncy and soft from years of estrogen. That's an irreversible change I live with. Getting my breast tissue surgically removed was a crucial step for me. It helped me re-establish my identity as a confident, physically expressive man. Before that, I felt emasculated. Afterward, I felt pride — I describe myself as more masculine than many men, both physically/athletically and in my understanding of who I am. It took a few years after quitting HRT to feel genuinely confident as a man, but I do now. I walk through the world with my eyes open rather than being pulled around by ideologies or identity crises. I still have problems, but I feel fully matured and able to process them while reaching for my goals. On the broader question of transition, I'm critical. I think a lot of people transition out of ego or a need to fulfill some narrative meaning in their lives, and I compare it to other dumb, damaging things people do — drugs, unsafe sex, traveling to dangerous places. I also think questioning people often default to believing their trans feelings are legitimate because the alternative — being a "trender" or a fetishist — feels worse. I've seen the "transier than thou" dynamics inside trans groups and find them tiresome. I'm skeptical of early medical intervention for youth. I've argued that puberty is largely complete by 16 and that the idea you've "stopped" puberty by starting HRT young is mostly psychological — people want to feel they achieved something. I also think a lot of people would benefit more from examining why masculine roles provoke a negative reaction in them, rather than medicalizing that discomfort. I don't oppose transition categorically, but I'm wary of how it's sold, especially around passing. I've told people to stop fixating on FOMO about physical outcomes, because for most people the fantasy of living unambiguously as the other sex won't come true regardless of when they start.