These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned woman (currently using Kate/she/her with close friends, previously Joseph/they/them) who had top surgery on May 27, 2021 after ten years of privately identifying as nonbinary, without ever being formally diagnosed with gender dysphoria. Two days after surgery I experienced suicidal ideation, and I have since been hospitalized and made another suicide attempt. My diagnoses now include bipolar II, anxiety, PTSD, OSFED, borderline personality disorder, and possible autism. I regret the surgery as irreversible damage, am pursuing DBT and eating-disorder treatment, and am considering breast forms and possible reconstruction after much more thought. I now understand myself as "the woman I've always been" and worry I may have made being trans look appealing to others.
Full story
I had identified as nonbinary privately for ten years and wanted top surgery the whole time. I started publicly identifying as nonbinary seven years before my first post here, changing my pronouns and then my name shortly after. I was very active on Tumblr and at my university advocating for trans peers — my friends called me the school's "token tran."
On May 27th of the year before I posted (I was keeping track — 285 days at the time of writing), I underwent top surgery. Before that surgery I had been diagnosed with major depressive disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, PTSD, and atypical anorexia. I was never formally diagnosed with gender dysphoria — I truly believed I had it and only spoke with affirming practitioners who told me I didn't need any diagnostic process. My therapist approved my desire for top surgery without question, even while my life was a mess.
Top surgery was supposed to change — even save — my life. All my issues were supposed to be manifestations of dysphoria. I'd made two suicide attempts in about a year, and I was certain they were because I couldn't bear living in a gendered body. Two days after top surgery I had my first post-op suicidal ideation. I've since been hospitalized for my mental health and made another attempt. My diagnoses changed to bipolar II, generalized anxiety disorder, PTSD, OSFED (otherwise specified feeding and eating disorder), and borderline personality disorder. It's also quite possible I'm autistic — at least all my autistic friends count me that way.
I realized a lot of the problems I was trying to solve through top surgery and identifying as nonbinary can't be solved that way. I have self-love and self-esteem issues, body image issues, and issues relating to people. I never liked how my breasts looked, but instead of learning to live with that or pursuing surgery to enhance their appearance, I cut them off completely. I think I'm also finally experiencing true physical gender dysphoria, or at least mourning the loss of that part of my body.
I'm 24 and I feel like my life was ruined. I sent my best friend — the only person who knew I was struggling with my identity — this text while drunk: "Like. My chest hurts all the time. Every time I shower or touch myself or see myself or breathe I know I'm not how I'm supposed to be. Even if I got reconstructive surgery it wouldn't be the same and I'd just be wasting money trying to recreate something that's gone forever. No one will trust me to make decisions for myself ever again. You say I'm attractive but I'm not to people who like men or women; I'm a weird, monstrous half creature. I did undergo irreversible damage in all aspects of my life and you expect me not to need to drink when thinking about it?"
I know I need lots of therapy but I don't know what kind of therapist will want to deal with all my issues. I think I want reconstructive surgery but want to proceed with caution so I don't do further damage. I know I need to effectively re-come out as a woman, but I'm scared my support system — many of whom are trans, including the people I currently live with — will disown me. I've picked out a "female name" but I'm not sure if I want to use it now or ever in lieu of Joseph. I will not go back to using the name I was given at birth due to trauma associated with it.
I'm also struggling with my beliefs about trans people in general. Currently I believe everything I used to except that I'm just a cis woman who made some serious mistakes. But I know not everyone who adopts a trans identity retains it and I'm scared for other people in my position. I'm so afraid I've participated in making being trans look cool and inadvertently ruined someone else's life as well as my own.
After my first post, I got off the phone with my therapist and we made a game plan to get me into a DBT program as soon as possible; I'm on several waiting lists for DBT programs. My therapist got me a referral to a dietitian for the eating disorder, and I have a psychiatrist appointment. I have therapy homework for the first time.
In my update about a week and a half later, my closest friends had started calling me Kate in private and using she/her pronouns. This feels really natural and I like it a lot. My therapist also recommended I try breast forms — I'm not in a position to wear them all the time and don't have much disposable income, but it's something I'd like to try. I'm having dreams about getting reconstructive surgery all the time, but if I choose that route it'll be after much more time and thought. I wrote: "I would not be coming into this more accurate understanding of myself as the woman I've always been without you all."
I regret the top surgery intensely — I describe it as irreversible damage in all aspects of my life, and I'm actively considering reconstruction. I also regret that my therapist approved the surgery without any diagnostic process. I'm fearful about how my trans friends and housemates will react to my re-coming-out as a woman. Regarding transition for others, I still believe what I used to except that I now see myself as a cis woman who made serious mistakes, and I'm worried I made being trans look appealing to others.