All stories

A pediatrician's doubts, from inside the affirmative model

Female · Desisted1.6K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a pediatrician in Oregon, not a detransitioned person; I am a clinician-ally who became critical of pediatric gender medicine through my patients and through learning that 99-100% of kids on puberty blockers proceed to cross-sex hormones. I have published critiques of the Dutch protocol and affirmative-only care, recruited detransitioners for research studies, run a post-top-surgery pain poll, advocated anonymous medical-board complaints, and appeared in the documentary 'Affirmation Generation.' I have worked to push the AAP toward a systematic evidence review and I continue to speak publicly despite professional risk. I currently identify as a concerned physician and advocate, not trans and not detransitioned. I have no personal transition history, regret, or mental-health crisis in this record.

Full story

I am a pediatrician in Gresham, Oregon, in private practice with a small independently owned clinic; I've been a pediatrician for over 20 years (I recall learning anatomy in 1988) and I'm 53 as of December 2019. I have an M.D. plus a Master's degree, and I'm the breadwinner in my family; I found my husband on Match.com and he has done more of the child raising, though we are both deeply involved. I am not detransitioned myself — I am a clinician and ally who became concerned about pediatric gender medicine through my patients. My concern began with patients: I described an evolution in a KevinMD article (October 2019) from 'well, let's send you to the gender clinic' to 'wait a second, can we talk about what you want before I send you to the gender clinic?' The turning point was learning that 99-100% of kids put onto hormone blockers continue on to cross-sex hormones — 'This was my first "wait a second, what?" moment.' I noted I can't think of any decision made by kids where 1% or fewer change their mind. I've documented four true patient stories in that article. In October 2019 I attended the AAP National Conference in New Orleans without a speaking slot, planning to ask pointed questions at a 'Tips for Improving Transgender Health' workshop and to bring a binder of detransitioned people's stories. At the 2022 AAP meeting I heard Dr. Jonathan Avila claim he'd worked with over 500 families with zero regret; I was skeptical and later wrote a post about it. At the 2019 AAP presentation on pediatric transgender medicine I asked a skeptical question and was 'mobbed by pediatricians in the audience, wanting more information from me.' One presenter said something like 'If we can do it, you can do it too! We're just making it up as we go along!!' I concluded 'none of them knew what they were doing.' I've published on these issues: with Stephen Levine and E. Abbruzzese, 'Reconsidering Informed Consent for Trans Identified Children, Adolescents and Young Adults,' and a 2023 open-access response in Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy critiquing the Dutch protocol (the 'Dutch Takedown'), which grew out of hostile peer review by Annelou de Vries. I know some authors of a 2020 Archives of Sexual Behavior paper on psychotherapy for gender dysphoria and shared it here. I'm a member of SEGM. I've said I've 'gotten the AAP to at least say they're going to do a systematic review of the evidence.' I've repeatedly recruited detransitioners for research: Lisa Littman's project, an Exeter study on transition motivations, Bath's Jane Lomax study of British female detransitioners, Chicago and other top-surgery surveys, and I ran my own poll on persistent post-mastectomy pain (of 50 respondents: 60% no issues, 32% persistent pain, 8% other persistent issues). I've advocated filing anonymous complaints with state medical boards, offered free tickets to a Genspect detransition conference, connected people to NewsNation reporter Rich McHugh, and helped source a New York Times article needing detransitioners. I appeared in the documentary 'Affirmation Generation' (2023). I planned to write a case series of detransitioners for the medical literature. Clinically I've prescribed estrogen cream to an FTM patient for stress incontinence, provided contraception (including Nexplanon) to adolescents without parental involvement, kept patients' homosexuality secret from parents, and prescribed sertraline and fluoxetine. I've discussed testosterone tapering with an endocrinologist and I'm in communication with gender-critical endocrinologists. I've counseled detransitioners on menstrual return, fertility, binding risks, lymph flow, and tapering off testosterone. I hold that medical transition in childhood is a mistake, that exploratory psychotherapy should be first-line, that being trans is not like being homosexual, and that transition is not the first thing to try. I've said 'Medical transition feels like a form of gay conversion therapy.' I'm politically not right-wing and bristle at being classified as religious or far-right, which I say happens to anyone near Portland opposing childhood transition. I watch Benjamin Boyce's videos, have read Blanchard on AGP, and created a public Twitter account under my real name. I've been downvoted and had posts hidden as spam on Reddit, and I feel like 'this is not my place' here, but I keep showing up. I'm active on Twitter and Reddit infrequently, and I'm aware of the risks of public identification given I live in Portland. I have no personal transition, detransition, hormones, or surgeries in this record. I've mentioned my own menopause took two years and was rough. I have no stated suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts.