All stories

Childhood dysphoria, no medical transition, and a neutral name online

Female · Desisted1K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned/desisted woman who experienced dysphoria from childhood but never medically transitioned, having only used a neutral name and pronouns online. I came to desist through critical self-questioning about the roots of my dysphoria and by discovering gender critical perspectives, which reduced but did not eliminate my dysphoria. I have ADHD and anemia, and I still experience monthly waves of dysphoria. I am now a vocal critic of youth medical transition and of the online trans community's influence on young people.

Full story

I was born female and have identified as a dysphoric desister. I first wanted to be male for as long as I could remember, and I experienced dysphoria involving womb envy, envy of not having a uterus or periods, and distress about my genitalia. I began planning a medical transition more seriously when I turned 18, but I never acted on it medically because I believed my parents "wouldn't understand." Instead, I only went by neutral pronouns and a neutral name online, which I described as the "safest" space. I also had a "he/they phase." I experienced PMS, which worsened my dysphoria, and I still get waves of dysphoria, at least a week a month, though less than before. What moved me toward desisting was critical self-questioning. I asked myself what exactly I was dysphoric about and whether my distress stemmed from romanticizing menstruation, womb envy, ignorance about women who don't have periods, or societal standards that prize male muscle builds and thin, porn-influenced female bodies. I realized that being a girl/woman would never go away, and I concluded that changing my body wouldn't change my lived experiences. Discovering gender critical views and abortionism significantly reduced my dysphoria. I also reflected on how I had been influenced online: I mentioned Tumblr, colored-haired people coming to my elementary school handing out pamphlets, wanting to be like internet "friends," and cult-like techniques online. I later described being "steered off the path" of medical transition, and I said that being afraid of rejection helped me reach where I am today. I also wrote about how I used to feel intense hatred toward my parents for their concerns about my transition plans, seeing them as transphobic, even comparing them to Nazis, before realizing their concerns about grooming and exploitation were valid. I am Jewish, as are my parents. I described my parent working in a hospital and having seen outcomes of these procedures. I wrote a post about how older trans people, usually MtFs, adopt parental mannerisms online toward questioning youth, which I found predatory, and how parents are vilified for any concern. I have ADHD and anemia. I mentioned having dysmorphia alongside dysphoria, and that watching my nutrition and doing physical activity helped me. I also mentioned having nightmares about the possibility of getting pregnant and being revolted by the thought of it. I do not want to be a parent. I have never medically transitioned, so there are no surgical or hormonal interventions or complications to report. I have never had surgeries. I am critical of transition for others, especially for children and teenagers, and I advise waiting until at least 18 or 21. I have advocated for gender critical positions online, discussed the medicalization of gender-atypical youth, and criticized the trans movement's treatment of people with differences of sex development and women of color. I have also discussed my views on autogynephilia, autoandrophilia, and the influence of pornography. I have not described any suicidal ideation or self-harm.