All stories

The women's choir and the case against surgery

Female · Detransitioned253
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who posts in support of others who have detransitioned or desisted, and I believe my own path saved me. I am strongly critical of medical transition, arguing that sex is immutable, that "transition" is a fantasy, and that surgeons and pharmaceutical companies exploit mentally ill people. I compare affirming transition to affirming an anorexic person's belief that they are obese. I have not shared medical, family, or mental-health specifics in these posts. I currently identify as a woman and value female community, such as women's choirs.

Full story

I came to this community in October 2019 to encourage another poster, telling them, "We think you look beautiful," and later thanking them for sharing their story. In November 2019 I told a poster who had written out their story that I was glad they were happy now, and that I hoped a young person might read it and be "saved just like you were" — which implies I see my own path to detransition/desistance as having saved me, though I never gave dates for that in these comments. My views on transition are strongly critical. In December 2019 I argued that "we don't let cosmetic surgeons and pharmaceutical companies take advantage of the mentally ill," and I insisted that "no one can transition to anything because sex is immutable. Any 'transitioning' anyone does is pure fantasy." I explained that the word "transition" itself is my sticking point: lots of women have breast reductions or full mastectomies for medical reasons, but that doesn't make them closer to manhood. I said that if someone wants to take "horribly unhealthy levels of hormones" or remove their breasts for cosmetic reasons, there's no good way to stop them, but that no one is actually transitioning into anything, and that it isn't helpful to tell people they can change their sex. I compared it to "agreeing with an anorexic who believes they are obese when they are objectively not." I drew a distinction between secondary sexual characteristics, which I called changeable and which occur in many variations in nature, and sex itself, which I called unchangeable — so there is no way to transition from one sex to the other. I also encouraged a poster about their voice, saying it "would be prized and cherished in many a woman's choir," which suggests I identify as a woman and value female community. Beyond these comments I did not share details in this transcript about my own ages, medical interventions, mental health diagnoses, therapy, family situation, sexuality, or the specific intensity of any regret, so I have left those areas out rather than speculate.