All stories

Five years as a man to make attraction feel straight

Female · DetransitionedFirst dysphoria 15 → Transition 15908
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned, bisexual woman who identified as trans for about five years after exploring gender at 15, partly hoping male identity would turn my attraction to women into heterosexuality. I detransitioned and now identify as a gender-critical, radical-feminist, gender-nonconforming woman, though I still experience deep, persistent dysphoria and sometimes ask close friends to use he or she pronouns. My transition was entangled with adoption trauma, a childhood BPD diagnosis (later removed), suspected undiagnosed autism, maladaptive daydreaming, and dissociation. I regret the years lost to an obsessive focus on passing and the rigidity of my trans identification, and I feel isolated navigating criticism from both trans allies and conservatives. I support waiting before medical transition and more holistic gender therapy, while respecting individuals' pronouns.

Full story

I am a detransitioned, bisexual woman who was born female. I identified as trans for about five years, starting to explore gender at 15 when I thought that if I were a man, my attraction to women would become heterosexuality. I was the classic gender-nonconforming kid with early signs of homosexuality — I almost took on a boy's role in my daydreams, friendships, and acting, because that was the only space where I felt not judged for loving girls and for being, bluntly, mannish. I knew before I liked men that I liked women, and femininity felt hard. In high school, girls seemed to know I was gay/bi without me saying it; I was accused of having crushes on friends, girls turned their backs on me in the locker room, and I started changing in the stalls. I was obsessed with passing and cried hard because I couldn't pass — I thought if I didn't pass, there was no point in living. I was ready to never speak to my parents again because they wanted me to wait before medical transition. I had bad mental health issues and adoption trauma, and I'm angry at myself for attaching so rigidly to trans ideology. Looking back, living as a trans person felt like a costume or a role. I couldn't even go into the women's clothing section with friends. I now align myself with radical feminism and consider myself gender critical, while keeping most of those criticisms private because friends and allies aren't open to nuance. I respect people's pronouns and don't want to judge individuals, but I get frustrated when people — especially female individuals — say they never 'felt like a girl' as proof they aren't a woman. I have PCOS, which makes me feel like 'an ox,' and I get misgendered constantly because of my bob haircut and PCOS symptoms — people jump to he/him or they/them, which drives me insane. I've been called transphobic for saying 'men and women' instead of 'men, women, and nonbinary people,' and told my language is 'binary' when I say I love women rather than 'non-men.' After detransitioning, my moderately traditional mother was excited and bought me dresses, taking me shopping for cutesy outfits — most of which we returned because I felt I had to impress her. She expresses sadness each time and tells me that when I wear boyish clothing, men won't like me. I describe my style as softly masculine/androgynous. Friends have asked if I'm nonbinary or still trans, and a nonbinary person I went on a date with said, 'you are still trans it sounds.' I feel erased as a butch/gender-nonconforming woman by both conservatives and several LGBTQ spaces. I still experience deep dysphoria — not so much bodily, but something 'gnawing' deep within. I want to be male, and I'm also really proud to be female. Sometimes, in safe spaces, I ask a couple of friends or online contacts to use he or she pronouns (never they), while maintaining my female identity. I've thrown out gender labels besides my birth sex because labeling never brought me joy. I asked how to deal with being a dysphoric female without medical transition. I was diagnosed with BPD at a young age, but it was later removed because symptoms improved; I still technically fit the criteria, likely spurred by adoption and adoptive family dynamics. I was in special education and tested for various things, but I suspect autism was overlooked because it's often missed in girls. I also have maladaptive daydreaming, derealization, and dissociation. I feel the diagnosis at such a young age — plus therapists and family — made me feel I couldn't be trusted and that every emotion I felt was 'hysterical,' so when they disapproved of me identifying as trans, I 'stamped my feet even more.' I believe BPD is a more complex form of PTSD. I lurk on the actual_detrans subreddit. In a now-deleted post, someone angrily commented about how lucky I was to experience sexism and that I 'signed up for living as a woman' when I vented about being catcalled. I see detransitioners bullied in TikTok comment sections. I want to talk about my experience and feminism openly but feel I must walk on eggshells, prefacing everything with 'not everyone detransitions, I was just wrong.' I find detransitioning hard — 'you don't know how to act' — and I still sometimes feel slightly ashamed of liking women, wondering if I'll ever commit to a man.