All stories

Still calls it a choice — without mentioning her own timeline

Female · Detransitioned38
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who no longer spends my time trying to convince myself I'm a man, though I say my life otherwise hasn't changed much. I believe being trans is a choice people make, not something someone is, and I've argued forcefully that trans women are confused men invading women's spaces. I have not shared details of my own transition timeline, medical history, or specific regrets in these comments. I am critical of transition for others and openly hostile toward trans identities in this space.

Full story

I came to this community as someone who had already detransitioned and who now speaks very bluntly about what I think transition actually is. In a single day of commenting in February 2024, I laid out my views and a small amount of my own story. I told another commenter that my life is better "in the sense that I don't spend all my time trying to convince myself I'm a man," but I was honest that otherwise "it really hasn't changed much." That is the most direct statement I made about how detransition has affected me: the constant effort of self-persuasion is gone, but my day-to-day circumstances are largely the same. On the question of identity itself, I was uncompromising. I said being trans is "a choice you made," and I pushed back hard on anyone who seemed to treat it as an inherent state rather than something a person decides to do. I told one detrans person that it was "kind of sad" that they still did not understand that being trans was a choice, and I said another commenter acted "like you still think being trans is a real thing someone can be and not just a choice they make." I was equally direct about trans women. I wrote that men "willingly choose to dress up as women and go out in public trying to invade real women's spaces" and then act surprised when they are harassed for it. I said trans women "suffer because they're delusional," and I insisted that the original poster of the thread I was in was "a real woman." I framed my own position in explicitly sex-based terms: "As a real woman I refuse to acknowledge confused men. I've reported you, have the day you deserve." I did not hesitate to challenge other people's claims to womanhood in the space itself. When someone pushed back on me, I accused them of "invading detrans spaces to troll," called it "the most cis male thing ever," and ended with "sure you're a 'woman'. Lmfao sit down sir." I also mocked the number of trans people who were upset by my comments, writing that it was "hilarious" and asking why they "lie on this sub just to get your feelings hurt." I did not share any details in these comments about when I first experienced dysphoria, when I came out, whether I socially transitioned, whether I took hormones or puberty blockers, whether I had any surgeries, or when I detransitioned. I also did not discuss therapy, mental health diagnoses, trauma, family or relationship circumstances, sexuality, fertility, medical complications, or any specific regrets beyond the general statement that I no longer spend my time trying to convince myself I am a man. I did not describe any advocacy or activism beyond posting in this community. Overall, I come across as someone who is settled in her detransitioned identity as a woman, who views transition as a chosen behavior rather than an identity, and who is willing to argue about it forcefully.