All stories

A non-transitioner who posts in detrans spaces anyway

Male · Desisted462
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned... no — I am a male who never transitioned but post actively in detrans communities, arguing that transition is medical mutilation, that gender dysphoria is a meaningless diagnosis, and that gender is simply a synonym of sex. I compare transgenderism to a religion or sect and believe it is ideologically imposed, especially on children. I advocate for therapy to find root causes, exercise, and lifestyle changes instead of hormones or surgery. I hold that stereotypes reflect biology but shouldn't force anyone, and I reject both misogyny-only framings and feminism. I have no personal transition regret because I never transitioned, but I strongly oppose medical transition for others and encourage legal challenges to gender-affirming care.

Full story

I've spent a lot of time in this community commenting on other people's situations, and what comes through in my own contributions is a fairly consistent worldview I've arrived at. I was born male, and I've never identified as trans myself — my engagement here comes from strong convictions about what transition is and what gender actually means. I came to the view that transgenderism functions essentially like a religion. I've written that it 'promises salvation' and that once you're in it, 'you have to have faith and conviction.' I compare the community dynamics to sects — the idea that you join, give up your time and money, but feel good because you belong. I've said trans ideology spreads 'exactly same methods' as new religions, and that criticism of it gets shut down the same way criticism of Islam gets labeled Islamophobic. On the medical side, I'm strongly opposed to transition procedures. I've described transition as 'steroid abuse and body mutilation in a flawed attempt to fake your appearance as opposite sex,' and I've said medically unnecessary surgeries and steroid abuse are 'never good for your health.' I've compared gender-affirming care to lobotomy, to amputating limbs for Body Integrity Identity Disorder, and repeatedly to affirming an anorexic person's belief that they're fat. I've argued that if a doctor won't perform a lobotomy or cut off a healthy limb on request, breast removal and genital surgery shouldn't be an option either, unless medically necessary like cancer treatment. I've blamed the system rather than individual doctors, saying the system should encourage exploring root causes of distress instead of giving people what they want. I've encouraged people to sue and set legal precedent, suggesting GoFundMe campaigns for lawyer fees. I'm deeply skeptical of the diagnosis of gender dysphoria itself. I've called it a 'cop out diagnose' and a 'BS diagnose' that tells you nothing about underlying issues — unlike a flu diagnosis, which points to a virus. I've argued the diagnosis is ideologically dependent on accepting 'gender identity' as separate from sex, and I've used the analogy of 'fitness dysphoria' — wanting to be an elite athlete and needing doping to affirm your true self — to show what I see as the absurdity. I've acknowledged a counterargument about schizophrenia and admitted I needed to read up on it. I've also cited a statistic that over 60% of children with dysphoria no longer experience it, which I take as evidence the condition is environmentally triggered. My own theory is that dysphoria is a product of 'mental conclusions based on environment and experience' — I've argued that someone raised in isolation from knowledge of the opposite sex couldn't become dysphoric, unlike schizophrenia or cancer. I hold that gender is a synonym of sex, and that the alternative meaning was 'pushed by John Money' and then spread like religious belief. I've rejected the idea of gendered brains as 'linguistic nonsense' — 'Your liver has no gender, your heart has no gender.' I've said 'brains have no gender. It's simply an organ.' I've also rejected the concept of 'feeling like' a gender: 'you can feel something, but you can't feel like something.' I've argued gender identity is 'a made up idea' and that there are just men/women and individual personalities. On stereotypes and gender roles, I take a moderate line: stereotypes exist and won't go away because they reflect biological predispositions, but no one should be forced into them. I've told people that preferring short hair or 'manly' clothes is fine without needing to identify as the opposite sex — 'You don't need to identify yourself as bird in order to fly a plane.' I've pushed back hard on framing things as patriarchal norms, saying calling a dress or corset patriarchal makes the word meaningless. I've also pushed back on posts that only mention misogyny, insisting misandry is an equally relevant factor — a couple of those comments were heavily downvoted. I've said feminism 'in any form is cringe' and that I care about both women's and men's rights equally. I've been critical of what I see as narcissism in some transition-related posts, and I've argued against policing speech, saying disagreement is where dialogue starts. I've told people considering detransition that they don't owe anyone an explanation — they can just quietly use their old pronouns and ghost counselors. I've reassured people that in the real world it's trans people who face stigma, not detransitioners, and that they should 'get off reddit.' On practical matters, I've recommended psychotherapy to identify underlying causes (bullying, body dysmorphia, childhood trauma, assault), exercise and sports for feel-good hormones, vitamin D for depression, and home photo-depilation machines for hair removal. I've shared a personal detail: 'in long past I worked as security in clubs and stadiums,' where I dealt with constant verbal abuse and trained myself to stay calm through self-talk — I use this as an example of how you can retrain your emotional responses. I've also told people that if their body still produces healthy testosterone they'll be fine, and that going to the gym can boost masculinity naturally. I don't express personal regret about transition because I never transitioned. My stance toward transition for others is broadly critical and opposed in the case of medical intervention, though I've allowed that people can experiment socially without permanent consequences — trying makeup or clothes is reversible. I don't describe any activism beyond posting these views online.