All stories

Wishing to be a boy for years, then choosing to stay a woman

Female · Desisted578
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned/desisted woman — I never medically transitioned but spent most of my young life wishing I had been born a boy, and I now identify as a straight, childfree, tomboy adult woman. I believe trans identification as currently framed is social contagion rather than an immutable identity, and I actively advise others against hormones and surgery. I still experience some dysphoria and wishing I was male, but it has lessened with time, therapy-like self-work, exercise, and stopping rumination. I have anxiety, social, and anger issues that persist. I am compiling sources to support my arguments against affirmative care and research shutdowns.

Full story

I was born female and I am female. I never knew what transgender was until the summer before I started college in 2016, and I have said that had I learned about the idea earlier I likely would have tried to get on testosterone. I grew up as a straight tomboy: I loved men's clothing, combat sports, weight lifting, video games, skating, 80s punk and synth pop bands, and I had an undercut haircut. I never wanted children and I hated having periods because I never wanted to use my reproductive system. I got my period at 13, just barely turned 13 or right before, and I felt too young for it; I envied friends who got theirs at 15. I resented having to wear a bra, clean up blood clots, learn to use tampons I hated, and deal with cramps that made me unable to stand, while the boys I knew only worried about homework and video games. I built up a huge amount of resentment toward boys and wished every day I had been born a boy. I used to picture myself growing up into a male adult, and only very recently imagined myself growing up into a woman. I have broad shoulders, a very small chest, and I thanked God my chest developed small because I used to dream of exercising shirtless like the boys or wearing swim trunks to the beach with no top. I did not grow up knowing mastectomy for reasons other than cancer was a thing, and I have said that if I had known, I worry I might have gotten top surgery and regretted it. I never used a binder; sports bras gave me a flat chest appearance and I wore one every day in high school, college, grad school, and still today, not out of hate for my chest but because I prefer the flat look. I love to lift weights and run, I work in a male-dominated career field, and I am a cell biologist in the biotech field near where I went to college. My voice isn't deep but I can sound monotone without purposeful feminine inflection, and people read that as masculinity. I have never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries, no puberty blockers — and I have repeatedly urged others not to transition, telling them to save themselves the regret of amputated body parts and a ruined endocrine system, and to seek therapy that is not trans-affirming to get at the root of why they want to transition. I have said no one is born in the wrong body and that being transgender as an immutable truth is not a real phenomenon, while acknowledging that dysphoria, body dysmorphia, body integrity disorders, and feeling lost are very real experiences I have personally felt. I believe the rise in trans identification is social contagion and I have been critical of activists for shutting down clinical research. I have been compiling sources on these claims. It took me decades to become more confident in myself, and I still have anxiety, social, and anger issues; healing isn't linear. I still sometimes wish I had been born a boy, but the intrusive thoughts of wishing I were a man are less frequent when I cook at home, keep a workout routine, and stop ruminating — letting the feelings come and go has been the best long-term solution I've found. The gym is 50% of my personality; I spend hours building workout plans and gain confidence from gym clothes that make me feel good. I take birth control that stops my periods completely, and switching to it from the pills was the closest thing to gender euphoria I've ever felt. I am straight, always have been, and I am with a wonderful male partner, a musician with super long dark hair, who shares my values and interests. I still skate, lift weights, have an undercut (recut after growing out my extreme one during COVID), and love 80s music, but I'm not nearly as tomboyish as I was at 18, when I'd never wear skirts or fitted shirts and had one dress I wore to formal events and interviews. I got negative comments from people saying they were sure I was just a lesbian and to stop dressing so 'unisex' if I wanted a boyfriend; I had horrible luck dating in college and suspected I'd have better luck as a trans man or a lesbian but didn't have the courage to read about those identities in depth, mostly suffering in silence. I never was a lesbian or a trans man. I turn 25 soon (in early August 2023), and I've found that in my mid-20s the highs are less high and the lows are less low. I identify as a straight, childfree, tomboy adult woman.