These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Full story
I was born female and I have never transitioned socially or medically, and I don't intend to. I'm writing this as someone who had gender dysphoria — or what I later described as strong gender incongruence, not quite strong enough to be full dysphoria — and who worked through it without transitioning.
Long before talk of trans identities became mainstream, I would pretend to be a boy. Not socially or publicly — I never knew that was an option — mostly just in my fantasies. I begged my mum to let me get my hair short like a boy so I could pretend more easily, and I did get mistaken for a boy a couple of times after the haircut while I was still a juvenile. That always felt awkward, but not because of the misgendering — I thought it would be embarrassing for them when they realised their mistake, and I was never quite sure whether to correct them and get it over with or let it continue and risk greater embarrassment later.
I have a memory of learning about an intersex athlete on the news — it was a big controversy at the time — and getting excited because it was the first time it occurred to me that a person could be thought to have been female when born but actually turn out to be male. I asked my mum with hope if I could be like this athlete. She denied the possibility, but gently.
I had this sense of congruence at least as young as six, probably younger, though I wasn't keeping track of the years back then. It continued mostly through high school, but I just learned to accept things as they were because I wasn't aware of having any other option. I have never been strongly suicidal, and I think that was made easier because my family didn't care two hoots about gender roles or gendered behaviour, and most of the women in my family are gender-non-conforming. None of us wear makeup or are particularly feminine.
I'm getting close to 40 now. My main reason for caring about this topic is that if I had been born a decade or so later, I probably would be one of the people in this community. I am certain I would have sought transition, at least socially, and been convinced by the arguments that transitioning was the best and only treatment for my dysphoria. Even if it had been successful, it would have been a harder and more expensive process than what actually happened, which is that I learned through lived experience to be okay with myself, both body and mind together.
I think my dysphoria was probably milder than the really intense cases, and that transition maybe is the best option for some people. But I still probably would have been convinced by the current narrative that I would be happier as a man, or at least that I was non-binary, which could have set me on a life of conflict with my body, with society, and likely with my faith. It would not have been true in my case.
I consider myself lucky that by the time I came across the concept of transitioning, I had already, as an adult, learned to enjoy living in my own body as a female, and learned that I didn't have to contort my mind to fit a mould but could just be okay with it.
In December 2023 I reflected on why I was able to navigate this. I wondered whether having a great mother was a factor in how I came to terms with my sense of gender incongruence when I was younger without taking drastic actions or letting it ruin my life. I framed it as: maybe it's less 'this is the main cause' and more 'those who don't have great parents have less resources to manage these feelings and are more vulnerable to maladaptive ways of addressing the distress.' I used the analogy that saying the cause of being poisoned by tainted water is lack of water filters confuses protection with cause. I also mentioned knowing a transwoman who told me she got a lot of toxic masculinity messaging from her parents — pressure to 'be a man', 'men don't cry' — and I could see how that might convince someone that if they can't be the right kind of man, maybe they'd be happier as a woman, or how it could aggravate pre-existing dysphoria in someone without a safe place to explore.
I also noted a possible overlap between OCD and being gender-questioning: OCD is about intrusive thoughts, and 'What if I'm trans?' may potentially become an intrusive, obsessive thought.
In October 2023 I asked the community whether I was welcome, given I had never transitioned and didn't really fit any of the user flags. I chose 'desistor' to make the post but wasn't sure it applied, since I never actually transitioned to have detransitioned, and I'm not really questioning at this point in my life. I'm pretty self-assured about who I am now, even if for no other reason than I had to learn to be.
I wrote a poem for the community called 'Our Names', really about questioning the need to find identifying labels to know who we are, and whether we can just know who we are without them. It references a slur but isn't using it against anyone.
In January 2024 I started a blog called 'Untransitioned' — living as my biological gender without transitioning — because I decided it may be worth writing about my experiences for the purpose of showing there is more than one pathway to peace. Mine might not work for everyone, as my 'dysphoria' was not extreme, but I wanted to share that there are other stories out there, to encourage others to find their own while questioning the major narratives being told.
On trans influencers, my main personal issue with both Buck and Blair is that I have seen them both ridicule other trans people for their appearance. Usually it's because they're saying stuff they disagree with, but they don't just target the argument — they make fun of how the arguer looks, which I feel is a cheap shot. I described a Blair reaction video where she mocked a non-passing male transwoman with blue hair and over-the-top makeup, only to realise the person was actually defending her, at which point she said 'Whoops, this is a fan, never mind! I feel bad now!' — which I felt was very telling. I've always felt Buck and Blair's joint reaction videos were in bad taste.
I've never been strongly suicidal and have not described any self-harm or suicide attempts.