All stories

Told questioning meant trans — then learned it didn't

Male · Desisted168
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned/desisted male — I never medically transitioned, but for about a year I believed I was trans because I'd been told cis people never question their gender. I experience gender dysphoria tied to being a short, underweight, feminine guy, and I'm still learning to accept myself as a feminine male. I now hold gender-critical views: sex is real, gender roles are a social construct we should disregard, and transition is not the solution to dysphoria. I support trans people living comfortably but am critical of the trans community and feel politically unwelcome on both the left and right. I'm glad I never decided to transition.

Full story

I never actually transitioned — I stayed a gender non-conforming male, and my story is more about nearly going down that path and pulling back. I've experienced gender dysphoria, which I describe as a very real mental illness, but I've never seen transition as the answer. My questioning started around late 2019. In November 2019 I admitted I'd only started being "sorta gender critical" the day before and that I wasn't "even 100% sure on where I stand." By mid-2020 I was articulating a firm position: "Being masculine does not make you a man and being feminine does not make you a woman. I've always found those ideas to be incredibly sexist." I described myself as "a pretty feminine dude" who tends to prefer femininity over masculinity, and who does sometimes experience gender dysphoria — but I was convinced "being trans is not the solution. You cannot change gender, and that shouldn't be of importance in the first place. It just sucks that decades of gender role enforcement exists." The dysphoria itself has been tied closely to physical insecurity. I'm 5'3 and underweight, and I've hated that for as long as I can remember. Combine that with generally liking femininity over masculinity, and that's the core of it. In June 2020 I told someone else questioning that I don't experience "tons of dysphoria but it's been hitting kinda hard lately," and that it was scary because I knew you can't actually change your gender, plus the backlash from transitioning scared me. I tried to be encouraging: "We're both gonna get through this." The most dangerous moment for me was a full year where I genuinely believed I was trans, because of the line "cis people never question their gender." I called that "a ridiculous and dangerous thought" and said I was glad I never decided to transition. That's the closest I came. On ideology, I've landed somewhere specific. I believe gender and sex are different — gender being masculinity and femininity, sex being male and female — and that gender is a social construct we should aim to disregard entirely. Pronouns, in my view, simply denote sex. I've argued that because sex is determined by something so small it shouldn't be your identity in the first place: "sex doesn't matter and you can be whoever you want to be." I've also theorized about why FtM transition seems more socially acceptable than MtF: girls being masculine is more accepted than guys being feminine, and patriarchy codes femininity as weak and masculinity as strong. I've felt politically homeless. In December 2020 I wrote that a lot of trans-critical people are hateful toward transgender people rather than just the ideology, often right-leaning with other discriminatory beliefs, while most people in my spaces are left-leaning: "It feels like we aren't welcome on either side." My current stance, from September 2022, is: "Trans people are cool; I support people trying to live as comfortably as they can. Trans community is awful though." The process of accepting myself has been slow. In January 2021 I said I was "still learning to accept myself as a feminine male." Things associated with femininity — makeup, long hair — don't have to be restricted to either gender, and I don't have to force myself to be masculine. I've never had surgery, never been on hormones, and have no medical complications or ongoing medical needs from transition, since I never transitioned. I don't describe mental health diagnoses beyond the dysphoria itself. I have no regret about medical interventions because there were none; my main relief is that I never decided to transition.