All stories

Told she was trans, then told she never was

Female · Desisted527
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a desisted, detransitioned woman who never went on hormones or had surgeries due to my family circumstances, though I socially presented as male at times. I experienced severe chest dysphoria starting around age 13 and was repeatedly pressured by peers — mostly college friends around 20 — to identify as trans and start hormones, while I believed my feelings stemmed from growing up in a conservative household. After desisting I was told both that I was definitely trans for questioning and later that I was never trans at all. As of late 2020 I still struggle with chest dysphoria and intrusive thoughts about mastectomy, though I actively help with detrans advocacy and push back on what I see as harmful narratives around transition.

Full story

I was born female. I remember being 13 and crying when my mom told me I had to start wearing bras; after that I basically never went outside without a sweatshirt to hide my chest. That chest dysphoria has stayed with me — as of late 2020 I wrote that being reminded I have gender dysphoria makes it much worse: usually I go about my day and then get "triggered" into remembering I have boobs and become really uncomfortable. I said I don't think I'll ever get to a point where I'll like them, but I'd like to not start considering a mastectomy every time I remember they exist. In preschool, when there were boy vs. girl games, I'd always go to the boy side because I fit in with the boys more. I had friends who were boys growing up. I was raised in a super conservative household. I watched 3-4 year olds at church every Sunday. I never went on hormones. I was told by others to start asap because it would save a lot of pain and suffering and that the later you transition the harder it is, but I was unable to go on hormones due to my family circumstances — and I noted that if I had, "yikes." I also never had any surgeries. I did socially present as male at times: I said I was never on hormones and still get assumed to be a dude most of the time, and that it's possible to present male while going through normal puberty. I desisted. During my questioning period I was repeatedly told "if you're questioning, you're definitely trans," and when I said I didn't really want to be trans I was told to shut up, that they had questioned a lot too, and that it would save me a lot of pain to start transitioning now. I was called an "egg" constantly for everything from wearing baggy clothes to being happy when I cut all my hair off. I told people over and over that I thought it was probably some sort of complex about growing up or being raised in a super conservative household, and was told I was just making excuses and should accept my transness so I could avoid more pain and suffering. I was also told by trans people that talking about it was internalized transphobia and made them feel uncomfortable. Then, oddly, when I desisted I was told "that's okay, cis people can question their gender too, how would you even know you're cis if you didn't question it?" Most of the people pressuring me were from my college — in about a year, nearly everyone I know from college came out as trans, all around 20 years old. So far none of them have detransitioned as far as I know. I got told by trans people that the detrans subreddit is just for TERFs and that the mods don't do any work (which I know is a lie), and also that genderfluid people should count as detrans. I noted that coming out as a desister is harder than coming out as trans, which I attributed to the narrative surrounding transness nowadays. As of November 2020 I was still dealing with severe gender dysphoria about my chest and had been told I was never trans and just made real trans people look bad. I did some advocacy/helping around detrans topics, though I said I was new to it and was careful phrasing my words. I also pushed back on claims about puberty blockers, noting potential long-term effects like loss of bone density and that coming off them isn't as simple as restarting puberty, citing research on hormone treatment causing bone density loss in older men treated for prostate cancer. I questioned the idea that cis people never question their gender and pushed back on the idea that breaking stereotypes is a sign of being trans.