All stories

Four years on estrogen, then counting the cost

Male · Detransitioned841
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a male detransitioner who lived as a woman and took estrogen for about four to five years before stopping around October 2019. I detransitioned because transition felt like setting myself up for failure — the cost of surgery, knowing I'd never be satisfied, being treated like a subhuman in relationships, and worsening anxiety that made me drop out of three semesters. I'm left dealing with gynecomastia that hasn't resolved off hormones and am considering an inverted-T reduction surgery. I don't regret transitioning overall, though I grieve the years lost; I now believe transition should be a last resort and that too many warning signs go unevaluated before hormones and surgeries are approved.

Full story

I was born male. I started identifying as trans and transitioning, and I was on estrogen for nearly half a decade — about four to five years. My evaluation before starting was rushed: only about two or three visits with a psychiatrist where I talked a little about my life and why I wanted to transition, and other things weren't really explored. I did get diagnosed with dysthymia. I went to therapy a few times but it wasn't really for me, though my therapist was cool and tried to give me some resources. By 2020 I had detransitioned; my post in June 2020 was titled '8 months off estrogen,' so I came off hormones around October 2019. I felt like I was digging myself into a lifetime of misery and setting myself up for failure. I don't regret transitioning really, but some of the major reasons I detransitioned were: the cost of surgery was insane, especially FFS (facial feminization surgery); even with surgeries I knew I would never be satisfied with my body; being treated differently, especially in relationships — I said this one 'kind of fucked me up' and that I was treated like a subhuman in a lot of interpersonal relationships; and anxiety became worse. Even though I passed 99.99% of the time, I always felt the need to wear makeup and look a certain way, and I dropped out of like three semesters because the anxiety attacks wouldn't stop. I also reflected that it's so ridiculously easy to get hormones, and that there's a high prevalence of abuse and mental illness among trans people — I believe transitioning should be one of the last resorts to treating gender dysphoria. I understand how someone could think transitioning is the answer to being uncomfortable with their bodies and sexuality during teenage years and adolescence, 'because I did that exact thing.' I used to scroll through old pictures of myself as a boy while I was still transitioning and feel so bad for taking years away from myself, chasing the delusion of transitioning; I thought I looked perfectly fine and happy and that I ruined it. Transitioning made every little thing about life so much harder. After stopping hormones I dealt with gynecomastia. My endocrinologist strongly suggested waiting to see if the testosterone my body produces would change anything regarding breast size; after about seven or eight months I saw no changes. I saw a plastic surgeon who suggested that because my breasts were pretty developed, an inverted T incision would be my best option and it would leave scarring. I had a checkup with that surgeon in the fall of 2020. I also asked someone else whether their insurance covered surgery, since I had been told to wait eight more months and wasn't sure how it would look to an insurance company. My voice is something I use as 'a cool little party trick sometimes' — always funny hearing reactions. It bothers me a tiny bit if I ever get mistaken as a teenager, but it can't really be helped. I cut off all my hair after keeping it long for about four years; my parents asked why, but transitioning isn't really a topic we've openly talked about because of how upset both parties get. They were always very against me transitioning, and there was always a bit of a language barrier, but now I'm able to fully understand their stance. I advised someone in a similar position to just straight up tell their parents they don't want to deal with transitioning anymore. I've been lurking the detrans community for around a year as of mid-2020 and I don't see anything hateful there. I browsed gendercritical while it was still around because I thought there'd an overlap of similar experiences, but a lot of it turned out to be hateful — I called out someone for using transgender slurs and being spiteful and got downvoted, and I was glad it was banned. I sometimes think about transitioning again, but those are just fantasies; I'm not equipped enough to handle all the problems that come along with transitioning. It's a topic I don't like openly talking about, but reading someone else's post helped me understand myself a bit more, and I'd never really tried putting my feelings of autogynephilia into words before. I noted that the surgery/suicide statistic is something I haven't really looked into, and that kind of stuff always seemed a bit more like autogynephilia to me. On the broader question, I think there is definitely a weird push to transition. I don't think transitioning is right for everyone with gender dysphoria, and a lot of the specialists who evaluate those kinds of things are fearful of being 'transphobic' or 'gatekeepers.' It makes me a little sad that J.K. Rowling is seen as transphobic. I believe transitions that stem from abuse, internalized homophobia, low self-esteem, poor mental health, self-hate, and sexual fantasies are all too common and often make people's lives even more complicated — these are warning signs that aren't thoroughly evaluated enough when hormones and surgeries are approved. It genuinely upsets me that even questioning someone's transition can be seen as transphobic. At the same time, I think as long as someone is making informed decisions and happy at the end result, there's nothing wrong with treating gender dysphoria however they want. I've offered support to others going through detransition, telling them to message me if things get overwhelming.