All stories

One year on testosterone, no regrets, still not a man

Male · DetransitionedFirst dysphoria 13 → Transition 29 → Detransition 30140
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I detransitioned in late 2019 after about a year on testosterone, and I now present masculine while still identifying as nonbinary, though I've described myself as a detransitioned man. I don't regret transitioning overall but feel I was misguided and should have dealt with my past trauma first, which included childhood experiences and a BPD diagnosis. I had no surgeries, and going off HRT was motivated by wanting to regain facial hair, upper body strength, and weight loss rather than deep regret. I'm happier now than I ever was presenting as female, though I still don't feel like a man. I remain supportive of trans people in general while believing transition isn't always the solution.

Full story

I came out as trans in 2018, around the time I was almost thirty, after years of struggling with my identity — I had previously come out as asexual, gay, nonbinary, and finally realized I was bi, though my feelings for women were always complex and hard to explain. Coming out as trans felt like it helped clarify things for me at the time. I had been diagnosed with BPD and, having spent about three years living on my own after my mom died, I felt I had more of a sense of myself than someone in their teens, so I decided to see a therapist before medically transitioning and initially put off hormones. I eventually went on testosterone in 2018 and stayed on it for about a year. By November 2019 I decided to detransition. I don't regret my time presenting as female, but I realized I wasn't happy being one. I had been in and out of crisis centers many times, and what I really needed to work on was my past trauma and building an idea of masculinity that suited me. I described having lots of untreated trauma, negative men in my life, traumatized women who distrusted men, and a feeling that I'm not really a male. I also mentioned going through a similar experience to a commenter as a child, along with other trauma, and said I've never felt like a man — I still don't, but I'm happier now than I ever was presenting as female. Going off HRT, I wasn't sure what to expect and was honestly scared the dysphoria would come back, but I didn't want to be on it anymore. Reasons I wanted off included wanting to lose weight, missing my facial hair and upper body strength, being tired of food cravings, and above all not wanting to be on it forever. I did acknowledge things I liked about HRT — it had somewhat restored my hairline, I liked not stinking or having foot odor, and I liked having less body hair — but decided these weren't worth staying on for. I had no surgeries, so I recognized my perspective might not be shared by others. Detransitioning actually felt nice — I don't worry about makeup, doing my hair or nails anymore; I just get dressed, slick my hair back into a ponytail (I like having long hair), and get on with my day. I said I don't think the outside needs fixing and although I wish I hadn't gone on HRT, or at such a high a dose, I'm fine and my life isn't ruined — I'll just continue living my life. I still identified as nonbinary but was presenting masculine and fine with male pronouns at that point. I described myself as a detransitioned man in comments. I planned to get help with my trauma, saying it's what I should have done before transitioning, and intended to go back to the gym. I also mentioned maybe growing out my hair, losing weight, and getting a new wardrobe. I don't hate trans people and I'm not against transitioning, but I don't think it's always the solution. I don't see being transgender as a delusion or misguided in general — I just accept that I was misguided in thinking I was transgender when I was merely in the nonbinary/agender spectrum, and I don't blame others for that. I pushed back against Blanchard's theories as discredited, and rejected being told my experience was a fetish, saying I wanted to be a woman to feel right in my own skin and that it had nothing to do with sexual attraction to myself. I also stated I'm gay and have no interest in women. I got frustrated with gender-critical posting on the detrans subreddit and told a commenter to go back to gender critical, saying I came here for support, not to further an agenda. I've had dysphoria my whole life since I was a teen, but I'm now 30 and wonder if it's just related to trauma.