All stories

Argued gender is appropriation — without saying she'd transitioned

Female · Detransitioned152
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman whose English is not my first language. In November 2022 I argued in the detrans community that changing gender is a form of appropriation comparable to racial appropriation, and that womanhood is rooted in lived experience rather than physical passing. I stated I could only speak from my own experience but did not elaborate on my transition history in these posts. No mention of suicidal ideation, self-harm, or medical details appears in the supplied material.

Full story

I posted a genuine question on the detrans community in November 2022 and then argued my position across a series of replies over two days. My central view was that transitioning gender is, to a certain extent, a form of appropriation — because if you are not, for example, a cis woman and you transition, then you are appropriating what a woman is to some extent. That is at least the way I view it. I found that I had yet to come across an answer that made sense to me. From my point of view gender and race are similar because they are both stuff society shapes us to be, so in my opinion it is a case of appropriating gender when you change your gender, same as it is when you change your race. I edited one comment to acknowledge that I realized I was ranting, and clarified that gender dysmorphia is as real as body dysmorphia. For me, womanhood is about experiences and dealing with society, so it does hurt me to see it appropriated or just reduced to a change of clothes or makeup — not saying that all cases are like that, but most of the ones I came across. When someone pushed back, I replied that I don't think that's a fair thing to say at all, and that reducing womanhood to just passing physically is hurtful. A woman is about experience you gain throughout your life, pain you feel on the regular and life lessons. So no, I wouldn't say it's okay to transition because gender is just physically passing as the other sex, because gender is a whole lot more than just that. I also insisted that gender is a whole lot more than just body parts. I acknowledged that womanhood is not exclusive to women and that's why I said 'for example,' because I can only talk about my own experience. I said I personally would feel both hurt by someone pretending to be a woman just as I would if they were pretending to be my race, but that we can agree to disagree. I also thanked another commenter for saying that gender is more than body parts, and noted that English is not my first language when someone understood me despite my unclear phrasing. Beyond these posts, I did not share details about my own transition timeline, medical history, mental health, reasons for detransition, or current identity in the supplied material.