All stories

Twenty years interviewing transitioners — and calling it an addiction

Male · Desisted286
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned... no — I am an adult male who has never transitioned or detransitioned; I am a beat writer and author who has covered the trans subject matter since 1996/1998 and identify as a detrans ally rather than a detransitioner. I have written two books (Unacceptable Losses, 2009; The Transsexual Delusion, 2016), run transgression.com, interviewed over 100 transitioners, and followed subjects for 15-20 years. I theorize that transsexualism in sexually developed people is a behavioral addiction rooted in autogynephilia/autoandrophilia rather than a genuine gender identity disorder, and I advocate anticonvulsant therapy as a treatment, while acknowledging this link is theoretical and anecdotal. I am an atheist, have received death threats (notably in 2008), and have been banned from r/asktransgender. I continue to advise people considering transition to seek anticonvulsant therapy and warn of cross-sex hormone risks, and I am producing a documentary on gender transition.

Full story

I am an adult male who has never transitioned or detransitioned; I have been covering the trans subject matter as a beat writer since 1996, and on the trans subject area specifically since 1998. I have been aware of my sex since I was 18 months old, which I consider the point at which sexual identity is formed, and I do not spend energy on what it is like being male — it is simply what I am. I self-identify as an atheist with no affiliation with any church or religion, and no affiliation with groups like the Heritage Foundation. My work has centered on the theory that transsexualism is not a genuine gender identity disorder in sexually developed people but rather a behavioral addiction — akin to sex addiction, internet addiction, or gambling addiction — rooted in autogynephilia (in males) or autoandrophilia (in females) coupled with an addiction disorder. I have written two books on the subject: Unacceptable Losses (2009) and The Transsexual Delusion (2016), and I run the website transgression.com, where I have written the vast majority of the articles. I was webmaster of www.wildside.org from March 1998 to December 1999, which at the time had the largest traffic of all trans sites in Canada, and webmaster of transgression.com from 2003 to 2005, which took over the highest traffic in terms of trans visitors from wildside.org. CTV News included me on a list of experts on the trans subject matter, which I was asked to join two years prior to releasing my first book. My research process began in 2000, when I conducted my first interviews. I have said I went in intending to report positive experiences after transition, but found no one whose life improved after transition — instead I encountered horror stories, death, suicide, loss of employment, despair, and anguish. Over the years I met over one hundred self-identifying gender transitioners in various stages of transition, the majority early in their transition, and I interviewed approximately 12 individuals who underwent at least one feminizing surgical procedure. I followed these subjects — the ones who did not die or commit suicide — for the next fifteen to twenty years where possible. I also followed a group of women from 2001 to 2008 who, in my observation, all aged poorly, with a number dying in their fifties. I met three individuals at a transition support group who, after undergoing anticonvulsant therapy for an ancillary medical condition, watched their interest in gender transition evaporate, only to return when the medication was stopped; I reported on one of these cases in depth in my book. The treating psychiatrist for that case, Dr. Frank Cashman of Toronto, Ontario, Canada, observed a cause-and-effect relationship between the anticonvulsant therapy and the subject's proclivities toward gender transition, though Dr. Cashman never spoke publicly about the patient. I have also reported that according to Dr. Cashman, only 10% of all patients take their medication for disorders like epilepsy, and that 90% of all patients neglect to take their medication. I have been criticized and, in 2008, received death threats every week. I have also been banned from r/asktransgender for posting material. Despite this, I do not hate transsexual-identifying people; I have said I watched a number of my subjects die due to ancillary addictions, while others are alive but on disability, having to pay for their antidepressant medications, which the Canadian government does not cover. I have advocated for what I call anticonvulsant therapy as a treatment for the addictive nature underlying gender transition, pointing to a case in Jan Wålinder's Swedish study of 43 case studies (case number 15) in which a subject's proclivities toward gender transition vanished after twenty days on anticonvulsants, only to return when the medication was stopped. I have claimed there is no case of an individual who takes anticonvulsants for an ancillary disorder and continues a gender transition, across reports of 143 or 243 case studies dating back to 1954. I have acknowledged that the link between transsexualism and anticonvulsant therapy is theoretical and anecdotal, that I have not personally performed proper scientific research to prove the relationship, and that no formal study exists. I have also noted that Milton Diamond has been advocating that transsexuality should be treated as an addiction since the late 1960s. I have been critical of Walt Heyer's religious approach to recovery, saying I cannot support Jesus as a proper treatment for autogynephilic addiction disorder, while also thanking him for his advocacy on the detransition subject space. I have expressed concern about avoiding unnecessary detransition, which I consider physically costly. I have been critical of clinicians at clinics in the Greater Toronto Area, including the Sherbourne Health Centre where I receive primary health care, arguing that trans medical practitioners are not arms-length from the phenomenon. I have also been critical of Paul Wolscht (Stefonknee), a patient at that centre. I have been active in posting to r/detrans, offering advice to people considering or questioning transition, suggesting they consult a medical practitioner about anticonvulsant therapy, and warning about the health risks of cross-sex hormones, including claims that females on testosterone have a 300% greater risk of heart attack. I have defended this as nothing illegal or inappropriate for a non-medical practitioner to do, noting that people on r/detrans routinely give advice to take cross-sex hormones. I have also produced and promoted a feature-length documentary, The Men & Women Who Transgress Gender Norms, through Transgression Film Studios, scheduled for release in June 2021, and have sought candidates including current and former transsexuals, spouses, parents, radical feminists, academics, medical practitioners, and politicians, including self-identifying detransitioners.