All stories

Cycling between man and woman — and blaming the OCD

Male · Desisted182
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a heterosexual man, born male, who has cycled for years between feeling confident as a man and intermittently feeling like a woman, while strongly suspecting the whole pattern is trans OCD (TOCD). I have never medically transitioned and am firm that I don't want hormones or surgery, calling HRT 'snake oil.' My recurring fixation centers on perceiving my legs/thighs as female and on not fitting Blanchard's AGP or HSTS categories. As of my latest posts I identify as male, describe myself as 24M, and am trying to 'regain the maleness that seems so lost right now.' I have not described any suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts.

Full story

I'm a 24-year-old man who has been going back and forth on questions of gender for what feels like a long time now, and I'm writing this to lay out where I actually stand. I was born male, and by my own account I've mostly presented as male throughout my life. I do have what I've described as a feminine side, but I always found it embarrassing and decided not to indulge in it. There have been periods where I took real pride in my masculine self — I remember sitting around in my mess dress thinking about how smart and smug I looked, and I remember feeling my muscles grow as I lifted heavy weights. Those are memories I hold onto. The confusion started intermittently and has been going on for around two years as of my first posts in September 2023. I described struggling with sleeplessness over it, feeling like my apartment was a prison and that I was wasting away. At its worst I'd dissociate and feel like a husk. I've gone back and forth constantly — from feeling fairly confident in being male again, to feeling like I'm completely a woman, and it makes me happy to think that way, and all I can see is a woman through everything. I've used what I called a 'smile test': saying 'I'm a man' feels like a lie but my smile is proud and confident, while saying 'I'm a woman' feels like truth but the look of disgust on my face is immense. I started following Blanchard's typology as a tool to figure out what was causing this. I concluded I'm not AGP and I'm certainly not gay — I'm heterosexual, present as male, usually comfortable in my male gender, and don't show AGP tendencies. That made the whole thing more confusing, because I couldn't locate a cause. I've asked repeatedly in the community whether others have felt like the other gender, whether 'gendered feeling' is nonsense, and what desisted males make of the 'feminine essence' theory. I've described the feeling as 'feeling like a girl,' 'feeling girly,' or 'feeling feminine' — essentially what MTFs say when they say they feel like women. A specific fixation emerged around my legs and thighs: I described perceiving and feeling as if my legs are women's legs, and that most of the 'feeling like the other gender' revolves around what I called 'mythick thighs.' I wondered whether it's just insecurity about having thick thighs as a man, and whether I'd be more confident with them as 'female,' or whether it's some weird dissociating. Sometimes I look at my legs and it elicits either a negative or positive response, which I found awkward since I'm mostly convinced I'm just a regular dude with obsessive thoughts. On causes, I've repeatedly floated the possibility that this is OCD or TOCD (trans OCD), and I've said that given my post history it almost certainly is. I've also considered that my inability to accept a feminine side may have made it 'an absolute mess in terms of personality.' I've never described trauma, abuse, family dysfunction, or parental pressure in this material. I've mentioned occasionally watching porn but said the sissy hypno stuff disgusts me and that after 'testing' I know for a fact I'm not AGP. On medical questions, my position has been firm and consistent: I know for a fact that I don't want hormones or SRS, reading the effects is very much a negative, I've said HRT is 'snake oil,' and that surgeries will only leave me with unhealthy limbs. By March 2024 I wrote that after much introspection and enough Reddit scrolling to kill a small dog, I'd come to the conclusion that not only is transition not on the table for me, I flat out don't want it — there's no drive, emotional or sexual, to be a woman. I've never described undergoing any medical transition, so there are no irreversible changes, complications, or fertility concerns to report. Mental health-wise, I've referenced OCD/TOCD, dissociation, identity crisis coming 'in ebbs and flows' and getting quite annoying, and a 'relapse in gender feelings' as of July 2024. I haven't described therapy, diagnoses from professionals, medication, self-harm, or suicidal ideation in this material. As for where I am now: in October 2024 I posted as 24M, saying there are times when I'm pretty stable in my male identity, while also finding the recurring feelings odd and annoying. I asked for advice on how to change this outlook and said I'd just try to regain the maleness that seems so lost right now. I've expressed appreciation for others' inspiring responses, particularly seeing 'the light behind your eyes.' I haven't described any advocacy or activism. I haven't described a sexuality shift before or after anything, since I never transitioned — I've consistently described myself as heterosexual. I don't describe myself as detransitioned or desisted in the strict sense, since I never medically transitioned; I'm a man working through recurring gender-related obsessive thoughts and trying to settle into my male identity.