All stories

Advising strangers off hormones, without telling her own story

Female · Detransitioned32
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned person who, in 2020, was active in detrans spaces advising others to get off HRT and warning that transgenderism as a movement can capture people who simply lack confidence, leading to unnecessary surgery. I have not described my own transition or detransition timeline in these posts. I currently hold a critical view of transition as offered by the movement and encourage others to reconsider hormones. My own medical details, mental health history, and current identity beyond being a critical participant in detrans communities are not stated in this material.

Full story

I have been posting in the detrans community since around May 2020, and my comments reflect a fairly critical view of how transition is pushed onto people. In one thread I wrote that "this can be the problem with transgenderism as a movement, it can capture those who simply lack confidence and potentially lead to unnecessary and damaging life changing surgery," and I congratulated someone on coming through it. I have given direct advice to others who were on hormones but seemed unsure. I told one person that if they were tired of their dating and sex life they should put it on pause for a couple of months rather than pursue what I called "chemical castration," saying it didn't sound like they needed HRT and they'd be better off without it. In the same vein I suggested getting off HRT, starting to work out, waiting until they found a girl they genuinely cared about, and in the meantime not worrying too much — "theres always masturbation and a one night stand every known and then won't hurt." I wished them the best. To someone else who had been sitting on a decision for a while, I encouraged a cautious, incremental approach: "maybe just try it and take it one step at a time, see how you feel." I also told another person plainly to "get some help bro." In June 2020 I posted a throwaway political quip — "Western Liberalism be like" — which fits the generally skeptical, culturally conservative tone of my other comments. My own transition timeline, medical history, reasons for transitioning, and details of any detransition are not something I have written about in these particular posts, so I will leave those out rather than fill them in. What these comments do show is that by 2020 I was actively participating in detrans spaces, discouraging others from staying on hormones when I thought it wasn't warranted, and framing transgender activism as a movement that can sweep along people who are really just lacking confidence.