All stories

Stepped back from the brink — and found a different fight

Male · Desisted1.3K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned or near-transition man — I came close to transitioning but never did anything permanent — and I now identify as a man who is critical of gender ideology and of the political left I once was devoted to. I have a loving fiancee, a good job, and credit Jordan Peterson's clinical advice with helping me find peace in my role as a male. I have argued extensively that transition is more detrimental than beneficial, that gender ideology functions like a religion, and that I am happy I never did anything permanent to my body. I have said that being obsessed with fighting gender ideology is a net positive for me, better than having transitioned.

Full story

I am a man who came close to transitioning and did not, and I now spend a fair amount of time thinking and writing about why. I have described myself as quite a feminine guy, with a digit ratio I describe as extremely low-testosterone, and I have said that I came close to going down the road of transition but never did anything permanent. I have written that I am happy I never did anything permanent, and that I would have gone much more in darker directions if I had not found Jordan Peterson. My own story, as I have told it, is very closely tied to a life of being deeply devoted to leftist ideas about the world. When I was single, did not know what to do with life, and was not sexually active, I was constantly scanning for a quick fix, and the thought "maybe I'm a faulty man" came up many times — though I have noted that nobody ever encouraged that thought. I have said that I got my shit together as an older male, around age 30, and had my share of sex partners after that, and that I now have a loving fiancee (elsewhere a girlfriend) with marriage and family being planned, with career as my top priority. I went through the PUA (pickup artist) movement at one point, which I said gave me some happiness in my role as a male after getting a good job and having sex. What finally brought me peace, I have said, was Jordan Peterson's clinical psychology advice and his reasoning about life — I said it made me comfortable with settling down and being more empathetic, and that I honestly think I became a better partner and human from it. I have been critical of Peterson's religious views in his later books, calling them unscientific, but I value his earlier clinical work. I have been deeply skeptical of medical transition throughout these posts. I have argued that there is no scientific proof that transition works beyond people saying "I am sure it was good for me," and that comparing mental health outcomes in trans people to the wider society shows worse outcomes. I have compared gender ideology to a religion, arguing it has no scientific support, functions as a way of dealing with homosexuality (citing Iran), and involves a kind of sacrifice — sterilizing children and spending thousands on surgeries. I have compared the situation to Lysenkoism, arguing that ideology is being used to ignore reality, with the result being healthy bodies destroyed and people unable to have gay or straight relationships, losing sexual function and fertility. I have also argued that historically, hormones and blockers were used for chemical castration — citing DES and Alan Turing's punishment for homosexuality — and questioned how being a lifelong medical patient balancing an untested concoction of drugs historically meant for cancer patients and medically castrating convicts could be an improvement. I have said I fall back on the basic medical principle "above all else, do no harm." I have been critical of the political left throughout, describing myself as a Western Chauvinist who believes western empires have been far more benevolent than most societies throughout history. I have said I feel the modern left pushes people into transitioning if they are not at the top of the hierarchy already — if you don't have a perfect waistline you must be a man, if you're not in the top 20% of guys you must be a girl. I have also said that softening or widening gender roles was a good thing, but that the left has gone too far. I have been involved in gender-critical discussions online and have recommended resources like Nina Paley and the Heterodorx podcast. I have said that being obsessed with fighting gender ideology and how badly people are hurt by transitioning is a net positive for me — better than having transitioned — and that it might actually help others, comparing it to a bee sacrificing itself to sting a predator. I have also said that I don't think people need to transition, but I don't hate or fear those who do, and that trans is the only mental illness we treat by leaning into it rather than giving mental treatment. I have described the detrans community as split and united only by shared experiences, and I have noted that my own story would probably have been received differently if I had framed it as a critique of conservatism or as a gay man raised in a religious household, but that my experience was very closely tied to leftist ideas. I have said I live in a country with many parties in government and growing parties of socialists who are also conservative, and expressed sympathy for detransitioned leftists in the USA who feel they have no political home.