These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a gender critical, gender nonconforming lesbian who has struggled with dysphoria since childhood but never socially or medically transitioned, identifying as trans/non-binary only internally. I trace my dysphoria to a hyper-religious upbringing, resentment of female socialization, and difficulty relating to other women, and I've chosen not to transition due to health risks, the ordeal of coming out, and a desire not to reinforce the idea that gnc women aren't really women. I currently identify as a gender nonconforming woman and hope my existence might help other gnc women feel comfortable in themselves. I have not undergone hormones or surgery and keep testosterone as an unappealing last resort.
Full story
I am a gender non-conforming lesbian who has struggled with gender dysphoria for years. I never actually began social transition — I only considered myself non-binary or trans internally — but the desire to transition has been with me since childhood and has grown stronger over time, like "a parasite stuck in my brain." I describe myself as gender critical, though not strictly a radfem, because I don't like subscribing to one fixed set of ideas.
I've analyzed where my dysphoria comes from: a hyper-religious and therefore sexist upbringing, resentment toward my female socialization and the way I'm treated for being female, and a general difficulty relating to other women. I do not believe it's possible to have the brain of the opposite sex, and I don't believe gender is innate — I know gender roles are just stereotypes. Yet I can't shake the constant feeling of wrongness. I want to be a "good feminist" and accept myself as a gnc woman, but the desire to transition persists despite my gender critical views.
My current reasons for not transitioning are the health risks associated with testosterone (including undesired effects like hair loss) and the fact that coming out would be a huge ordeal. Previously, I also only wanted to be a biological male rather than a trans person, but now I don't even care about that distinction. I'm putting testosterone on the back burner as a last resort — I don't want to do anything I regret, but it's not off the table.
I have strong relationships with some women, but I don't think any of them would understand my situation. I'd like to know other gender nonconforming women or men, but I don't. I don't relate to men any more than to women; since I am a woman, that's my only point of reference, and I have a hard time relating. Things considered integral to being a woman — desire for heterosexual marriage, having kids — are large parts of other women's lives and make me feel alienated and like an "other." I'm not straight, and I'm not interested in marriage or kids. I know I'd be an outsider as a man too; I don't have an idealized idea of what being a man is like.
I have read Stone Butch Blues, which I had mixed feelings about but enjoyed overall; it helped to have gnc female representation, since 99% of female characters are gender conforming and heterosexual.
After Elliot Page came out as trans in December 2020, I was honestly crushed — not blaming him, but it highlighted a bigger problem for me. I looked up every gnc lesbian under about 40 I could remember and could only find Lena Waithe who didn't identify as trans or non-binary. I feel pretty hopeless: women who aren't even half as gender nonconforming as me no longer consider themselves women just because they don't dress exclusively feminine. The world hates masculine women, which is why I feel the need to identify as one. I don't want to be yet another gender nonconforming lesbian inadvertently telling other gnc lesbians there's no way they're actually women.
I support Elliot Page's choice to transition and am genuinely happy for them if they're happy; I don't believe celebrities have any obligation to stay a certain way. I hope my existence might help another gender nonconforming woman or girl feel comfortable being such. I also noted a nonbinary friend who wears makeup, dresses and skirts all the time and only sometimes dresses androgynously — if short hair is enough to make someone not female, then what am I?
I don't currently identify as fully "detransitioned" since I never medically or socially transitioned, but I consider myself part of this community because of my ongoing dysphoria and my choice not to transition.