All stories

Years of wrestling with masculinity, then dropping the labels entirely

Female · Desisted599
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born female and have never settled on a label for myself, though I've spent years wrestling with my masculine side, fantasies about being a biological woman, and severe comorbid mental illness including depression. I've come to accept those feelings as fantasies I can't have rather than something to act on, and I now identify simply as myself without labelling my sexuality or gender. I'm critical of both trans-activist toxicity and of those who deny detransition is real, and I advocate stepping away from gender obsession toward self-acceptance and kindness. I have not described undergoing hormones or surgery, nor any specific detransition process.

Full story

I've never fit neatly into a label, and I've spent a lot of time thinking about gender, sexuality, and how other people perceive me. I was born female, and for a long time I struggled with my masculine side — it felt much harder to summon up than my natural feminine qualities, and I got bullied for it quite a bit. I had a long history of never feeling anger at all, especially when I was very, very depressed; I think it came from being so good at bottling things up that I didn't even realise I was doing it. Getting in touch with anger was the biggest hurdle I had to overcome — once I could feel it, the more masculine, 'manly' qualities became much more natural for me, though obviously it has to be tempered. I don't label myself as gay — I just don't bother labelling myself at all. I've had feelings I don't fully understand, including fantasies about wanting to be an attractive biological woman, but I've come to accept that these are fantasies I can't actually have. Getting better at accepting myself made it much easier to park those feelings and accept them for what they are. I still have those feelings, but now I'm okay with them. I've also been bullied about traits relating to these feelings, which cements them in ways other people don't get, and I still don't fully understand them — I just don't care to anymore. They are what they are, as am I, and I'm alright with that. I like the idea of sculpting a chiselled male physique, and it's nice to be naturally a little more physically capable. I like fit dudes and want to be one also. The more I think about the concept of gender and some people's obsession with it, the more it turns me off from thinking about it at all. I find that stepping away from gender and sexuality and stepping towards holistic understanding, self-improvement, and kindness is the healthiest approach: don't look for the in-group, be the group you'd wish to be a part of. I've dealt with multiple comorbid severe mental illnesses. I've also had a long history of depression. I've thought a lot about internal emotional congruence — the main goal for anyone, regardless of trans status, should be to feel in line with how things are in reality and to be at peace with yourself. I believe people are too quick to consider drastically changing their outsides before really considering whether what's inside is telling the whole truth, or rather telling them what they need to hear right now. I think trying to fix an internal psyche misalignment with transitioning, when in reality it might have been other mental issues, is a real risk. I have strong opinions about art — I love surrealism, creepy or uncanny art, and horror. Beksiński is probably my favourite painter. I also love art in video games, and I think about writing in games like Disco Elysium, or the metanarrative of an experience like Pathologic, for a long time. I recently read The Vorrh and loved it. I care about how people are perceived and how painful it is to feel invisible — I've said that I wish people who weren't ignored understood how painful the absence of being perceived is. I've reassured others that a normal person wouldn't think anything unusual about their appearance, and I've tried to be supportive when people are struggling, including telling someone not to kill themselves and that there are ways around the difficulties they're facing. I'm critical of how some pro-trans voices refuse to accept that detransition exists at all — they deny it, then justify why it's not real, then attack anyone with lived experience under the guise of outing transphobia. I think detransition is real, even if it's blown out of proportion by some people, and I want a sober appraisal of the facts rather than moral panic. I also think sections of the queer community will eventually have to deal with the toxicity and narcissism some members display under the armour of oppression, which ironically only marginalises people further. I've criticised tribalism and extremism on both sides of the culture war. I don't have strong opinions on everything — on some topics I've said plainly that I have no opinion and that something was just an interesting read. I usually handle questions about pronouns by saying 'I don't care' or 'whatever you'd like them to be'.