All stories

Part-time as a man at 17, four years without dysphoria

Female · DesistedSocial transition 18 → Desistance 1888
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned lesbian woman who desisted at around 18 after living part-time as male for a year, never taking hormones, and who has not had dysphoria in four years as of 2019. I was early-onset dysphoric, have a twin brother, and believe in-utero testosterone exposure may have contributed; the transition process was raised by my psychiatrist. I credit working on parallel psychological issues, self-acceptance, and embracing my lesbianism for my detransition. I hold critical views of current transition practices, especially puberty blockers and HRT without a dysphoria diagnosis, and I advocate for gatekeeping. I am happy now, though I still grieve that I cannot be male.

Full story

I desisted at around 18, after living part-time as male for about a year, but I never took hormones. Before that, I had early-onset gender dysphoria. The whole trans thing was actually brought up by my psychiatrist at the time, and I was in therapy for about two years; back then a gender dysphoria diagnosis was mandatory for hormones, you needed to be followed by a therapist, and the requirement for sex reassignment surgery was two years with a therapist plus one year living full time. I also bound my chest for about a year and I remember not being able to breathe from it. What helped me was realizing that it didn't matter if I ended up passing, because I would always know I couldn't ever be male and couldn't live my life pretending. I worked on the other issues in my life, which took many years and is still in progress, and I haven't had dysphoria in four years as of early 2019. I believe that if there are psychological issues going on in parallel, it's better to face them first, and if you still want to transition later on you can be confident it's the right choice. I've thought a lot about what drove me toward transition. I grew up being told all the things women shouldn't do or how they should be, and I used to avoid everything feminine. I notice a lot more regret with female-to-male detransitioners because of similar reasons I had, mainly sexualisation. I have a twin brother, and I know in-utero exposure to testosterone could be linked to homosexuality, so I think it makes sense it could also cause dysphoria. I was early onset too, and although I don't look particularly masculine (not petite but not broad either), I have similar reasoning and interests as men; female socialisation makes me overall very in between as an adult. I work with only men and prefer male friendships, so I'd be way happier as a man, but I've come to terms that some things in life aren't easy or fair. Learning to love myself more helped a lot, as did learning to appreciate being a woman. Now I can appreciate feminine things and not hate who I am. After detransitioning I tried seeing another psychiatrist and was assigned a random one; I checked his RateMD and it was 80% great comments and 20% people complaining about hormone gatekeeping and suggesting private psychiatrists to get HRT prescriptions. At that point I knew I got someone who did their job right. On sexuality: I'm happy, it's just one thing I can't have. Detransitioning didn't kill the movement for me; what did was finally accepting my lesbianism and having people push the idea of fluid sexuality and 'girl dick' and being called a bigot for saying misgendering is the smallest problem affecting trans people. I've recommended that others who are attracted to women explore how the lesbian identity feels. I also pointed someone toward r/truelesbians as a lesbian space that excludes bisexuals and trans women, noting these spaces don't really exist IRL. I have strong opinions about medical transition now. I think 18 is a fair age for hormones if they've been followed by a therapist for at least a year prior with no red flags (sexual arousal from transitioning, mental instability, trauma). I don't see a problem with social transitioning a teenager — by 15 or 16 it can be a mistake but social transition won't screw anyone up permanently. Puberty blockers, on the other hand, should be banned because HRT doesn't resume puberty; when you miss it it's missed. I always saw transitioning as a last resort for those with such crippling dysphoria that no other option would work, and I worry about giving HRT to people who don't show signs of GD. The worst part to me is a lifetime of medical problems — one of my female-to-male friends is in denial about his health and needs estrogen cream to minimise vaginal atrophy and might need a partial hysterectomy, which I consider inevitable on HRT for many years. I also worry about trans women developing prostate cancer or heart problems from T suppressors. In my case passing wasn't enough. I notice that even in very liberal circles the way we treat each other is unconscious, so passing or not is key to a happy transition.