All stories

Ten years of estrogen, then surgery he can't undo

Male · Detransitioned318
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned man who lived almost a decade as a trans woman after transitioning in high school, and who now identifies as male and regrets my transition. I had gender-reassignment surgery and a breast augmentation after roughly ten years of estrogen, and I deeply regret the GRS because I now face life as a man without a penis, which makes bathrooms, changing rooms, dating, and a normative sex life feel nearly impossible. A year of therapy helped me conclude that my transition was driven by body dysmorphia, childhood-bullying anxiety, and internalized homophobia rather than genuine dysphoria. I live stealth with a good career but feel I am living a lie, miss bonding with men and the strength testosterone gave me, and worry about the long-term health effects of estrogen with undetectable testosterone levels. I am now strongly critical of transition and of what I call gender ideology, which I say indoctrinated me as a minor.

Full story

I started questioning things in high school, and I now believe that what pushed me toward transition was body dysmorphia, anxiety rooted in early-childhood bullying, and internalized homophobia — not genuine gender dysphoria. I transitioned as a minor, during high school, and I am convinced that if I had been given time and access to a real mental health professional back then, I would have grown out of it and never transitioned at all. Instead I spent almost a decade living as a trans woman, and over roughly ten years I underwent hormone suppression, estrogen, gender-reassignment surgery, and a breast augmentation. I worked with a brilliant psychologist for about a year, and together we arrived at the conclusion that my transition was driven by dysmorphia and shame about being "a bit fruity" rather than by any authentic sense of being female. I had gender dysphoria before I transitioned, but it is difficult to know how much of that was actually dysmorphia and insecurity rather than real dysphoria. I no longer experience dysphoria about my sex or my body, and I have unpacked a lot of the mental health struggles I had 10 to 15 years ago. What I do feel is a kind of social dysphoria — a longing to simply be myself as a feminine man. I decided to detransition last year. The first couple of months were great and liberating, but over the following months I have experienced immense regret. I feel like a man trapped in a woman's body, and I don't know how to move past that. I feel sickly and weak, and given my size and what a decade of estrogen has done, I don't believe I will ever be able to integrate and have meaningful relationships with men. When I was younger I enjoyed looking like a twink, but as I have aged I have come to appreciate more masculine male appearances, and knowing that will never be an option for me — that if I tried I would just look like a masculine woman or a boy — is beyond frustrating. I live stealth, I have a great career, and I established my social circle as a woman, but I still feel something is missing. I miss bonding with other men beyond romantic affairs, the strength and physique testosterone gives you, and not constantly feeling like I am living a lie. I go to the gym with my boyfriend and seeing how strong and athletic he is makes me envious; the relationship he has with his male friends and how he is treated socially and at work are things I wish I could experience. My family is conservative and traditional; when I talked to my parents about my frustrations, my mom told me I can't be a man anymore because I don't have a penis and that I should focus on finding a family and conforming to womanhood. Medically, my testosterone levels are undetectable. I talked to my nurse about it and she shrugged and said that was the goal of "feminizing therapy." The only clinic willing to work with trans people where I live is a family practice run by nurses who will not prescribe testosterone to trans women, and I find it infuriating because if I were female with those testosterone levels they would have immediately prescribed TRT. I am concerned about what decades of estrogen will do to my physical and cognitive health, and years of estrogen have already resulted in some health issues I hope would improve on testosterone. I deeply regret my GRS. Everyday situations — going to the bathroom, using changing rooms, going to the beach — have become immensely difficult, and facing the reality that I may never date or have a meaningful and normative sex life is disheartening. I asked others who have detransitioned whether it is even possible to live a happy and fulfilling life as a man without a penis. I considered phalloplasty, but my impression is that results are very variable and many are left with gruesome complications, and I don't think I have the energy or stamina to go through that process again. I have also become much more critical of transition itself. I was trapped in an ideological headspace where I believed I could become just like any other normal woman, which is a lie that requires constantly living in the closet, which is exhausting. Changing social attitudes toward trans people changed my mind: I no longer believe in innate trans identity, and I no longer think gender dysphoria as a concept is always meaningful. That mental shift accelerated my desire to detransition. I have also publicly stated that trans people are indoctrinating children and young adults into gender ideology, signing my comment as "someone that was indoctrinated into gender ideology as a minor." I have looked for support circles and male-only servers for detransitioned males, and I have asked whether detransition actually helps and whether anyone regrets it.