These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Full story
I have never transitioned, and I am glad about that. Transitioning is impossible in my country, and I never did it — that is something I am genuinely grateful for when I look back on it.
My views on gender and dysphoria are pretty settled. I do not believe there is such a thing as a brain gender or a brain sex. Gender, as far as I am concerned, is purely a social construct and nothing more — there is no proof that gender actually exists beyond being a social construct. Personality traits exist outside of society, but gender does not. That said, I do think gender dysphoria is real. I see it as a legitimate mental issue caused by a mix of social, environmental and biological factors, much the way other mental problems appear — anxiety, OCD and so on. Even some trans people, the transmeds, agree that gender dysphoria is a legitimate mental issue.
Because I see dysphoria that way, I do not think transitioning is usually the answer. My view is that about 80% of the time transitioning is not the answer, and that people should instead work towards developing better therapy plans for gender dysphoria — even medication that could help them align with the body they were born with, if therapy alone is not effective enough. I doubt therapy would not be effective, though; I think it usually would be.
I also think there is a middle path that does not require medical steps. You can totally be a guy who looks like a girl — using makeup, having long hair, and so on — without getting surgery or HRT. In short, I am sceptical of medical transition as an approach, I believe dysphoria itself is real and deserving of treatment, and I am personally relieved I never went down the transition route myself.
As for what I actually did in response to these conversations, most of it was just arguing my position online: pushing back on the idea of innate brain sex, arguing that gender is only a social construct while dysphoria is a real condition worth treating with therapy rather than transition, and noting that non-medical gender expression is possible. One of my comments was just a terse suggestion to "work out?" in response to someone else's post.