All stories

An ally who never transitioned, defending the space

Female · Desisted272
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am an older female who has spent years in detransition and gender-critical spaces as an ally rather than as someone who transitioned myself. I have consistently pointed people toward resources like Pique Resilience, The Detransition Advocacy Network, and /r/gender_detox/, and I argue that listening to detransitioners improves how gender-questioning people are cared for. I am angry about the harassment detransitioners receive online and protective of their space. I caution young people to think about how transition will look at 50, not just at 25. I remain an ally to detransitioners, not a detransitioned or re-transitioned person.

Full story

I have been active in detransition and gender-critical spaces on Reddit since at least 2018, mostly offering resources and support to other people rather than telling my own story in detail. In September 2019 I answered a direct question about my sex with a single word: "Female." That is the clearest statement I have made about myself in this transcript, and it fits with how I write elsewhere — in August 2019 I commented "as an older woman," and in April 2020 I wrote about people "who have suffered from being born female," which suggests I speak from the position of someone born female who is now older. I describe myself as an ally to detransitioners, and I have never claimed to be detransitioned myself in these posts. In July 2020 I wrote that Twitter was catching fire "not only from allies such as myself but all the higher profile detransitioners too," which places me in the ally category rather than the detransitioned one. My contributions have been practical: pointing people to /r/gender_detox/, /r/GenderCriticalGuys/, Pique Resilience (piqueresproject.com), The Detransition Advocacy Network, TransGenderTrend, 4thWaveNow, gendercriticalresources.com, and Miranda Yardley's writing on autogynephilia. I recommended The Detransition Advocacy Network's Manchester conference in November 2019 and later noted they are global and offer support to all detransitioners, though their focus is young women. I have strong views about how detransitioners are treated. In April 2019 I wrote at length about being told that detransitioners and desisters do not exist, then that they exist in numbers too small to matter, and I argued that listening to them is "not only humane but also highlights the weaknesses in current practice working with gender questioning people" and can teach us more about gender dysphoria. In October 2019 I was angry about a detransitioned person called Charlie being attacked on Twitter, told she was never trans, and had a childhood photo used against her: "It's making me so angry. Just leave detransitioners alone to sort themselves out." I have also been involved in practical community questions — discussing whether the detransition subreddit should become a private, invite-only, detrans-only space, and noting that I am a member of a private sub myself (unrelated to trans or GC topics). In July 2020, during what appeared to be a Reddit crisis, I said I don't trust Reddit, that many people had moved to saidit.net, and that I thought the disruption was someone acting too quickly rather than a glitch. On transition itself I am sceptical and cautionary. I have advised young people to think about how they will be in their transitioned sex at 50 rather than 25, warned a poster that the attention they were enjoying would fade with age, and told another that wanting to be a "cute girl" would not work out: "You won't be. And you will grow old. How do you feel about being a middle aged trans woman?" I have also shared information about hormone-driven breast cancer risk. At the same time, I am not hostile in tone — I have wished people luck "in finding yourself," told one person "In the end that's the main thing... you're ok," and was glad when someone said this community helped them find themselves and prevented an irreversible step.