All stories

Watching gender roles harden while a girlfriend adds pounds to her squat

Male · Desisted65
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a cis man who has always identified as a man, with no transition or detransition history in my account. I value physical strength as something within our control, using my girlfriend's powerlifting progress as an example. I am critical of sweeping generalizations about either sex and have called out what I see as sexism from both men and women. I worry that gender roles have become more rigid and polarized over time, so that a man who likes makeup or a woman who chops wood is read as actually being the other sex. I have not described any dysphoria, medical interventions, or mental health struggles of my own.

Full story

I have been active in these discussions for a couple of years, and my contributions mostly reflect how I think about gender, strength, and how people relate to each other. Back in February 2022, I was encouraging someone who felt bad about her physical strength. I told her she could train to become stronger, using my girlfriend as an example: she had started powerlifting about 2.5 years earlier and couldn't do most physically demanding things like squatting or pull-ups, but by then she was pound for pound stronger than most men and definitely stronger in specialized areas like deadlift and squat. I told her that if physical strength was something she valued, she should pursue it, because it's "one of the only things we as humans can change about our bodies." I acknowledged that progress is individually dependent — I said I started off unable to bench the bar, while she was able to bench 95 pounds in her first 3 months — but I emphasized that everyone starts somewhere, it's a lifelong journey, and physical strength is within our control. In April 2022, I was responding to a woman describing tension with her partner around sexual expectations. I asked her how she would rather behave in contrast to how she did now, and how she felt he expected her to behave. When she made sweeping claims about men, I pushed back hard: I called one statement "sexist and a massive generalization," and asked whether she had talked about it with him directly, noting that from the outside her position seemed understandable. I tried to clarify what the actual problem was — whether it came from her assuming he wanted penetrative sex and her not being comfortable with that, and whether she just wanted to communicate more about foreplay before penetration. When she claimed she'd experienced 99% of all men and they all expected their partners to perform like pornstars, I told her to "think about what you're saying." I also asked whether she was holding back because there was "too much to get called out for your sexism" or whether she was just trolling. Later that month, when another commenter framed something as socialization as a man amongst women, I said that commenter and the original poster were being sexist, and sarcastically concluded that "so looks like all women are sexist." In February 2023, I agreed with someone arguing that gender roles are now seen as strict and enforced. I said it was sad to see things so polarized between genders now, giving the examples that "A man can't like makeup without him actually being being a woman and a woman can't like chopping wood without actually being a man." In September 2023, I commented on someone's appearance, telling her "You look like a woman," and I gave context about myself: "I'm a cis man that's always been a man." That is the clearest statement I've made about my own identity in this transcript — I have always identified as a man and have not transitioned or detransitioned. Overall, I come across as someone who is critical of sweeping generalizations about either sex, values physical self-improvement as something within a person's control, worries that gender roles have become more rigid and polarized rather than looser, and is willing to call out what I see as sexism regardless of which direction it goes.