All stories

Twenty-three years counseling thousands of cross-dressing men

Female · Desisted307
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a lifelong LGBT woman who came out young and faced street harassment in the era before legal protections. I hit an extreme low point — homeless, alone, and close to ending my life — but eventually built what I call the best years of my life, including a family. For twenty-three years my career has involved one-on-one work with many thousands of men with cross-dressing and related fetishes, which I have also given expert testimony about in criminal trials. I am strongly critical of what I see as trans ideology, particularly the medical transition of children, and I support detransitioners speaking out and pursuing legal action. I do not describe myself as having transitioned or detransitioned in this material.

Full story

I was born female and grew up during a time when being LGBT carried real physical risk. I came out young — as a young LGBT person I faced street harassment regularly: men pulling cars over to yell that they wished I had a dick, calling me a butch dyke, rolling up their sleeves trying to start fights with me. I got skilled at avoiding those situations. There were no legal protections for LGBT people then, and I remember how far the community had fought to get to where we were. At one point in my life I hit what I describe as 'the bottom of the bottom.' I believed my life was over and that I was ruined. I was utterly alone and living on the street. I had nothing and nothing to lose. I came very close to ending my life — 'I came so scarily close to exiting my body.' I don't give a date for this, but I eventually recovered to a degree I couldn't have imagined at the time: I later described experiencing 'the best years of my life' and having 'an amazing family for the first time.' Professionally, my career has been built around working directly with men who have cross-dressing and related fetishes. Over a twenty-three year period I have worked one-on-one with many thousands of men of varying ages, spending thousands of hours with them. I describe myself as an expert in fetishism and say I have served as an expert on fetishism during criminal trials. My work involved extensive interviewing — I say I 'extensively interviewed each one' and that people open up when they feel safe and trust the person they're talking to. I have personally cross-dressed thousands of men as part of facilitating this fetish. My conclusions from that work are firm: for the vast majority of these men cross-dressing is a fetish, not a sexual orientation and not gender dysphoria. It is often solely about the garments — the feel of the clothing, the taboo of a man wearing it. Out of over twenty-three years I can count on one hand the number of men I encountered who were experiencing genuine gender dysphoria, and notably those were all men aged 50 or older who had struggled for many years. I also note that among thousands of transvestites I met, none described themselves as 'trans'; the 'trans' framing has appeared only recently and primarily among younger people under 30, which I take as evidence that it is a social phenomenon. I have observed that early in my career men described childhood events or tactile experiences as the origin of their fetish, whereas more recently, especially after the rise of social media, they describe learning about it through porn or the internet. My best friend of 15 years is a cross dresser — straight, over 80, with half a dozen personas and a latex fetish — and I have his consent to share details of that. I am highly critical of what I call 'trans ideology.' I argue that transitioning does not change biological sex — it changes appearance only — and that telling children they can change their biological sex is 'pathological' and 'cruel.' I am angry about detransitioners being treated as acceptable collateral damage and labeled traitors by the pro-child-transition community, and I support detransitioners speaking publicly and pursuing legal challenges, including funding like Chloe Cole receives. I follow the WPATH files disclosures and am frustrated that other Reddit forums dismiss them as right-wing conspiracy. I have lost faith in research institutions, which I believe are 'neck deep in the ideology.' I have participated in at least one speaking event and know from experience what that involves; I distinguish that from legal challenges, which I support. I am not a transphobe, I say, but I believe anyone who doesn't go along with trans ideology will be labeled right wing regardless. I am frustrated that lesbians have been 'forced underground' and that 'conservative' lesbians are the ones 'grasping onto reality.' I am skeptical of doctors and the medical profession generally: 'It's called a practice for a reason,' and society's worship of medical professionals makes many of them think they have power over life and death. I am also skeptical of lawyers' motives in malpractice cases, saying we can't assign motive without hearing from the people involved. I am active online and aware of my communication issues — I have noted that I sometimes draft replies in notes before pasting them, that I've confused threads, and that 'online communication sucks.' I try to monitor how I write to avoid adding 'static.' I do not describe myself as detransitioned or as having transitioned in this material; my participation in this community appears to be as an ally and commentator.