These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned/desisting female who used to identify as trans and nonbinary, and I am currently unsure whether I am trans or a butch woman, deliberately postponing any permanent physical changes while I recover from abuse. I was raised by a homophobic mother with NPD, and I have CPTSD with dissociation, which I believe contributed to my chest dysphoria and my pull toward transition. I want a breast reduction for physical comfort but have avoided surgery so far. I hold transmedicalist views, support transition for some adults, and oppose youth medical transition. My main grievance is that Medicaid makes it far easier to access chest surgery than competent trauma therapy.
Full story
I remember dreading growing breasts when I was ten, before I had ever even heard of the word trans or of top surgery. I literally believed I could stop puberty with the power of my mind. Once my breasts grew, I would constantly dream of cutting them off with a knife. In kindergarten I was already questioning my parents' decision to send me to an all-girls school.
I grew up very sheltered — no TV, no secular magazines, no real exposure to information about transness — and I wasn't outwardly gender non-conforming because we wore school uniforms. So when people talk about rapid-onset gender dysphoria being driven by online exposure, I don't see how that explains me. I also questioned my body before I ever had access to any of that.
My breasts are genuinely large and physically uncomfortable. I'm 5'1" and 106 pounds, so weight loss isn't an option for me — I'm not overweight. Exercise and muscle building would help me feel more okay with my body, but the only way to actually get smaller breasts without starving myself would be a reduction, which I'll probably do one day. I've worried that if I get a reduction and still want top surgery afterward, that would mean double the scarring.
I used to identify as trans, and I also used to ID as nonbinary. I eventually left that identity. I'm still not happy being female, but I've been deliberately pushing off any permanent physical changes until I work on recovering from the abuse I went through. I could be trans or I could be a butch woman — honestly, who knows right now.
A big contributor to my dysphoria, I think, is my family background. I was raised by a homophobic mother with narcissistic personality disorder. Her expectations for her female children to emulate her were more intense than her expectations for my brothers. On top of that, any physical characteristics related to her — in this case, breasts — gross me out. That combination fed a lot of my dysphoria.
I have CPTSD and I experience dissociation. I've come to believe that dissociation causes us to feel disconnected from our bodies, and may influence us toward physically transitioning when we really shouldn't. Dissociation is a useful coping mechanism, but in people with CPTSD it keeps going even after the threat is gone, and that severely impacts interpersonal and work relationships and our ability to enjoy life — something I think we should work on overcoming in therapy.
I relate strongly to the line, "I wanted a man to protect me, but there was none so I became one." I also notice that a lot of people — and a lot of nonbinary people especially — seem to start out as lesbians.
I'd describe my views as transmedicalist: dysphoria is definitely real, and I do think transitioning is right for some people. But I also believe a lot of people assigned female at birth use a trans or nonbinary identity to get away from their trauma — because I was one of them. I think the modern medical and psychiatry system is failing to give trauma victims the support they need and instead pushes them toward transition. I'm not anti-transitioning; many trans people seem genuinely happy and well adjusted. I'm just skeptical about whether it's right for everyone who says they need it.
When I was in the trans community, non-dysphoric, non-trans people usually held more extreme views than I did — for instance, believing underage teens should be able to get gender surgeries. I always pushed back on that, because I knew it was possible to be dysphoric and still not be completely sure you want surgeries. They didn't know what dysphoria was like, so they were completely misguided about how to handle it.
I think both transitioning and detransitioning should be way less politicized. A lot of professionals adhere to performative wokeness at the expense of their clients. If I were seeking gender therapy, I'd probably go to a transgender therapist, because they understand the community in depth and, being trans themselves, don't have to worry about being called transphobic.
I don't think it's a matter of who's truly trans and who's not. I do think trans ideology is junk science, but if someone's life actually improves from transitioning, then good for them — as long as they don't pressure people to have sex with them or try to get other people to transition. And children definitely should not be allowed to physically transition.
One of my biggest frustrations is systemic: a lot of people transition due to childhood trauma, and it's a great failure of the system that it's easier for me to find someone to chop off my tits on Medicaid than it is for me to find a competent trauma specialist on Medicaid.