All stories

Surgery at 18, regret by 40s — and still on estrogen

Male · Detransitioned1.2K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned male who transitioned at 15 in 2001, had penile inversion surgery at 18 in 2004, and lived my whole adult life under a female identity. I regret the surgery and the false identity deeply, but I do not regret halting male puberty or taking estrogen, and I continue to take estrogen and progesterone after orchiectomy while identifying as male and as a eunuch. I have soft-detransitioned socially, dressing in men's clothes and no longer planning to legally or medically detransition, and I continue to live under a feminine identity at work and school. I attempted suicide several months before October 2019 and wrote a memoir as a suicide letter; my mental health remains poor and I no longer expect happiness. I advocate for eunuchism as an alternative to transgenderism, oppose SRS, and created the subreddit r/notwomen for self-aware feminized males.

Full story

I was born male and was, as far as I know, one of the earliest adolescent transitioners in the Western world. I began transition with spironolactone and estradiol injections at age 15 in 2001, and I had penile inversion surgery with Dr. Brassard of Montreal at age 18 in 2004. I lived my entire adult life, from age 16 onward, under a female identity, and all of my education and work experience occurred under that identity. I never completed male puberty. I was forced to bank a sperm sample in order to access anti-androgens, and I chose to destroy the samples ten years later, which I felt and still feel deeply violated by. I did not come to transition believing I was a girl. As a child I was frequently mistaken for female, had a strong sense of identity with girls, and had occasional desires to be a girl, but I also had little interest in stereotypically feminine things — the women I admired were fashionable and intelligent, not ultra-feminine. Around age 14, before anyone had suggested I could be a girl, I told an older feminist friend that I wanted to be free of sexuality; I knew the word "androgyne" from Vonnegut but not yet "eunuch." My earliest friends were girls until we approached puberty and grew apart. I read novels with female protagonists and identified with them. I was both horrified by my mother and overwhelmed by my feelings toward women. What actually drove me was a desperate wish to halt male puberty and escape testosterone and male sex drive. Around age 14-15 I was adapting to puberty until the sex drive became overwhelming and the physical changes undesirable, and I wanted to be androgynous. Pursuing androgyny was so disturbing to others, including my mother, that transgenderism was offered as an explanation and transition as the response. My mother encouraged me to wear female clothes, presented me with pro-gender-identity media, sought out trans support groups and therapists, and even chose my surgeon and sent me links to his website. My family would never have accepted me as a eunuch and an extremely feminine boy, but they accepted me as a transgender girl, especially since I could pass. I resented the social requirements imposed on me. I described the real-life test and full-time presentation requirement as painful: "It was essentially imposed female socialization on the basis of my wanting to feminize my body. What did wearing feminine clothing and training my voice have to do with wanting to change my hormone levels? It pushed me into thinking of myself as a girl, rather than a boy choosing to feminize himself. It took away my ability to enjoy androgyny and masculine aesthetic. I did it anyway, in order to get access to HRT." I did not go a full year before starting blockers. Presenting as 100% female was never my original goal; I just wanted to look more feminine and stop the effects of testosterone on my body and mind. During adolescence I had a girlfriend, and I could see the confusion and pain my transition caused her. Our sexuality was a major factor in escalating my dysphoria: I did not want to be the boy she loved, and I objectified her without meaning to because of the way her sexual image connected with my mind — I wanted control over that image and its effect on me. In adolescence I experienced intense envy and resentment toward girls as they became beautiful while I was masculinizing, which I recognize as an ugly, misogynistic current, though I never developed an overall negative attitude toward women and always took responsibility for my own feelings rather than blaming them. I also experienced being called "faggot" by men as a child, apparently because of how I talked or walked, and I learned to defend myself. I deeply regret penile inversion surgery and the years spent under a false identity, but I do not regret curtailing male puberty or taking feminizing hormones. I wish I had simply had an orchiectomy as early as possible — I wish I could have had it even earlier than 18 — and retained my male identity. I wish I could just have become a eunuch. I regret spending three years on spironolactone instead of having orchiectomy. Of the surgery itself I have written: "I had penile inversion. I think it is pretty bad. As far as I know, I have been luckier than most. It doesn't look 'real' and I can't imagine finding it attractive... Keeping clean is a distressing and embarrassing burden." I have not dilated in over a decade; the cavity has not closed, and I wish it would. I repeatedly corrected people who call it an "open wound": it is an artificial body cavity lined with penile flesh that healed years ago, and the claim that it would simply close if I stopped dilating is misinformation that is hurtful because it implies an option that does not exist. Penetration felt uncomfortable and unhealthy and was not something I was interested in even when I got the surgery; I saw it as the final step toward being an acceptable woman. I find I do not want partners to touch it even if they are okay with it or attracted to it, because it is too psychologically painful. I feel too horrified by what has happened to me to let myself be touched again, and I find the idea of someone being attracted to me in my current state extremely off-putting. I am incapable of meaningful sexual connection and I have tried to convince myself I became totally asexual, but I have not. I have described the surgery as having destroyed my chances of ever feeling natural, whole, or lovable. I wrote: "SRS really destroyed my chances of ever feeling natural, whole, or lovable." I also said, "'SRS' really destroyed my chances..." and that I could have had hormones and orchi and been "a pretty, very feminine boy, and kept my penis intact," and that the partners I had would still have been attracted to me, probably more so. Estrogen from an early age has kept me very youthful — I can pass for a woman or a teenage boy — and I like how my body looks superficially, but I am not able to feel comfortable in my skin. I began posting on r/detrans in 2019 under the username LumpyZone. Talking about my experiences there was very valuable for my mental health, but I deleted that account after two clearly non-detrans people harassed me aggressively about my own status for a couple of weeks. I regretted deleting it a week afterward but felt I needed to remove the temptation to visit and argue. I later returned under a different account. I created the subreddit r/notwomen as a private, gender-critical space for detransitioners, reidentified males, and questioning transgender males — self-aware feminized males who do not delude themselves into thinking they are or can become women. I have undergone a partial, social detransition that I call a "soft detransition": I have dressed in men's clothes for a few months and found that most strangers avoid gendering me, while those who do split evenly between male and female. I continue to consider myself male and a eunuch, though I see myself socially as more like a butch woman or a semi-passing FtM. I do not plan to legally or medically detransition; I continue to take estrogen and progesterone. I am male, castrated, and continue on estrogen and progesterone. I continue to live under a feminine identity while working and studying, and I have said I will keep living for now as if I were a GNC woman. I am comfortable with either male or female pronouns. I have said I haven't truly detransitioned, only reidentified. I don't think I will detransition because it feels too impractical for someone like me — I don't want a name change showing up in background checks, all my education and work occurred under a female identity, and I feel objectively permanently very different from an adult man and completely socially unprepared to live as one. My mental health is a mess. I experienced a failed suicide attempt several months before October 2019, and I wrote a condensed memoir as a suicide letter that I shared on r/detrans under the username LumpyZone. In my post "Moving on" (November 2019) I described that year as by far the worst of my life, with my mental health breaking down for reasons totally unrelated to my gender, far from home, impoverished, sick of pointless and alienating work, and lonely. I described my suicide attempt as an attempt to be a "psychic terrorist" or "ideological suicide bomber" whose death would ripple through the discourse, and I admitted this was narcissistic; I wrote that opening up to my grief over transition was overwhelming but that it was only a small part of my life, and that I had "better and bigger griefs." I said I still can't bring myself to be glad for my life. When asked if I expect happiness, I answered, "No. I no longer expect happiness." I have described myself as spiritually isolated, feeling the same existential horror I felt as a fifteen-year-old boy, with terror and revulsion at "the churning death and fornication of the universe" and none of the reverent awe I tried for years to feel. I have said my mental health is a mess and that transgenderism is a big part of that, since I lived a confused life under a false identity with the trauma of extreme, experimental, cosmetic genital surgery. I have been repeatedly harassed in the community: I was targeted with the slur "TERF," and in October-November 2019 someone contacted other users and made aggressive personal attacks on me, including calling me a "permanent retard," apparently angry that I hadn't fully detransitioned, was continuing estrogen, and talked about the barriers to detransition for me. I have also been called a "dyke" many times in adult life, which I find scary. I have written extensively about my views. I believe the minimum effective modification — orchiectomy and estrogen, with no change of identity — is acceptable, and that SRS should not even be an option, or at least should be illegal to market under euphemisms like "Sex Reassignment Surgery." I argue that eunuchism would have been a far better and more honest framework than transgenderism for boys like me. I am critical of transgender ideology, specifically the idea of an innate gender identity, while being ambivalent about individual choices to alter the body, and I have argued at length against GC users who I feel dominate the space, condescend to males, and treat the sub as an extension of their own political communities. I have also argued against the AGP/"true transsexual" distinction, saying no one is truly transsexual. I created r/notwomen partly because I felt I needed a space where I could discuss the feelings that led me to transition, including struggling with male libido, without being shamed or pressured to immediately detransition. I have advocated for firm ages of intervention, informed consent standards, no change of legal sex, no therapeutic gender affirmation, and cultural opposition to "TWAW" and WPATH, while also believing the underlying phenomena cannot be totally suppressed. In my final post, "Moving on" (November 14, 2019), I said I did not think this latest bout of internet addiction had been good for my mental health, that I was tired of the constant invasion of people with no stake in our problems, and that I had learned I have no real stake in this cultural conflict and no ability to influence its outcome. I said the only positive outcome of my engagement had been meeting a vanishingly small number of sensible people on its margins, and I planned to keep away from these discussions as I had for almost twenty years before.