All stories

Cancelled top surgery at the three-year mark

Female · Detransitioned150
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who lived as a man, was on testosterone for about 2.5 years after roughly 4 years of social transition starting at age 22, and quit T cold turkey around the three-year mark while cancelling a booked top surgery. I don't regret transitioning exactly, but consider it a waste of 7+ years of my life; I'm not unhappier now, and I've learned to manage residual dysphoria with CBT rather than medication. Detransition cost me many friendships — some supporters turned openly hostile — though my parents stayed supportive throughout. I developed hypothyroidism after starting T and lasting body-odor changes, and it took about 8 months to settle hormone-wise after stopping. I now support gender-nonconforming people but am critical of mainstream trans activism and believe medical transition should be a rare exception.

Full story

I was born female and grew up as a straight, gender-nonconforming girl. The first thing I remember being exposed to that shaped how I saw myself was Coach Beiste on Glee — she wasn't even especially masculine or butch, but the show covered a lot of the issues masculine straight women face, and I was genuinely happy to see someone like that on television. Then they transitioned the character, and I always resented that, because it was one of the first times I was exposed to the concept of being trans and it probably had more than a little to do with how I saw myself at the time. Socially transitioning was a long and difficult process — I was out but did not pass, and I very much knew it. That phase lasted about four years. Medically transitioning, though, felt like freedom and happiness and everything I had wanted for a long time: ecstatic, euphoric, all the good feelings. I started medical transition at 22. T was awesome for about two and a half years. After that things started to go sideways. The stress crept back, the depression, the dissociation, and eventually the dysphoria. I was booked in for top surgery at the time and ended up missing several appointments from a combination of depression and fear of surgery. Around the three-year mark I quit T, cancelled top surgery, and started looking at alternate options for dealing with my mental health. I never spoke to my medical provider about detransition — I lied and said I was moving away when I cancelled my last appointment, and went cold turkey. In total I was on T for about 2.5 years, and the whole transition period plus detransition felt like a waste of 7+ years of my life. Things I noticed medically: I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism after starting T, though I think there were symptoms before T too, and I've often wondered whether the depression from the thyroid caused the dysphoria or whether the T caused the hypothyroidism. I also noticed body odor changes — within about a month of starting T, in the middle of summer, and two and a bit years after stopping I still smelled strongly after eating onions or garlic, which was never a problem before. After stopping T it took about eight months for things to settle down hormone-wise, and I was warned (and warned others) that T can cause mammary gland atrophy and that binding right after stopping is a bad idea while things are tender and swollen. The beginning of my detransition was probably the second lowest point of my life — or perhaps the end of my transition period was. It's complicated. Letting go of the comfortable delusion of my 'gender identity' was difficult. The mental process was difficult, but the social change was in a way far more intimidating: a lot of people in my life who had been so supportive suddenly vanished or became hostile. Many people who were supportive during my transition were outright hostile about detransition — I was mocked, told my dysphoria wasn't real and that none of my experiences mattered, told I should shut up and never talk about it because I was a threat to 'real trans people.' My LGB friends, who had been more blasé about my transition, were fine with my detransition. My parents were a little disappointed that I was 'giving up' on the thing I had promised them would make me happy, but they were incredibly supportive throughout both my transition and my detransition. I was fortunate to have some friends who had my back through the process. On names: I changed my name when I transitioned and changed it back when I detransitioned. I actually dislike my birth name — it's after someone I never knew and nobody can pronounce it correctly — but I went back to it legally as a kind of 'thank you' to my parents for their support. Most people who knew me by my masculine/trans name disappeared from my life. My family had always used a neutral nickname that was a shortened version of both names, and that's what I use all the time now; my work, friends, and anywhere that accepts a preferred name know me by that neutral nickname. What actually helped me was finding straight or straight-partnered bi GNC women on social media. Getting away from constant trans rhetoric and seeing these women living kickass lives as GNC women made a huge difference in how I could see myself and, more importantly, my future. It's brutally difficult being a straight GNC woman because there's nothing for us — no 'I wanna be like her when I grow up.' Either it's conforming straight women or GNC lesbians, never anything in between, and it's easy to get lost. I also found that cognitive behavioral therapy and actively working through my dysphoric feelings did far more good and far less harm than transition did. While social transition and T did mitigate most of my dysphoria, it was temporary and had long-term health consequences. I was told by multiple therapists that transitioning was the only 'cure' for dysphoria, and I can only imagine how much easier and cheaper my life would have been if a therapist had been willing to work with me to combat my gender issues instead of validating them. Now, more than a year and a half after detransition, I don't know if I'm any happier, but I'm not unhappier. The difference is sustainability: I can exist as me without medications or artificial hormones and without paying for the privilege of just being. It's taken a lot of work, but I'm finally comfortable as me. There are still moments where dysphoria rears its head, but I've given myself the mental tools to deal with it, and it's pretty easy to dismiss when it shows up. I don't think I'll ever be totally free of dysphoria, but I've come to acknowledge that many people have moments of strongly disliking their body and that I can deal with it. I don't really regret transitioning, but it does feel like a bit of a waste of 7+ years of my life. I don't consider myself fully happy about how things went, but I support GNC folks wholeheartedly — seeing a man rocking a dress brings me genuine joy, and I can even support cross-sex hormones as a form of body modification. That said, I believe a man is an adult human male and a woman is an adult human female, and that people who genuinely need to transition are extremely rare and should be the literal exception to the rule. I think new laws forbidding criticism of gender ideology are going to hurt people and children, and I'm pessimistic that this will continue to hurt a lot of people in the future. My advice to others considering surgery is simple: surgery is permanent, waiting is temporary. I've also noticed what seems like a not-insignificant number of detrans women with thyroid problems and have suggested others get theirs checked.