These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned/desisted woman who identified on and off as FTM for about 10 years, socially transitioned once and then changed my mind, and have lived as a butch lesbian for the past 5 years without ever taking testosterone. My dysphoria comes and goes in cycles alongside cyclothymia and depression, and I've been caught between obsessive online trans fantasy and fear of losing my hair, attractiveness, health, relationships, and place in the lesbian community. I've tried managing dysphoria through building muscle and through time in relationships, both of which help somewhat, and a post about testosterone's health risks helped snap me out of a trans obsession. I'm currently seeking support and staying with friends to get my mind off transition, and I remain uncertain about my identity. No suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts are described.
Full story
I've identified on and off as FTM for about 10 years now, and I've never been on testosterone — partly because of health problems and partly because of money. I did socially transition at one point, then changed my mind, and I remember everyone around me being chill and even relieved that I wasn't going to go on T after all. Even so, I've stayed stuck.
The intensity of my dysphoria comes and goes. Some days it's fine; other days it's absolutely disruptive and soul-crushing. For the past 5 years I've been living as a butch lesbian, but I can't shake the thought of transition. It gets much worse when I see trans men online, especially attractive ones who pass well — I desperately want to be like them. At the same time, I know I'm a reasonably attractive butch woman, and I worry that if I go on T I'll lose my hair like my dad and brother and just become less attractive overall. I also worry about transitioning and then later having a phase where I'm more okay being a girl and wondering what I did to my body. Because my waves of dysphoria come and go, I don't want to destroy my life socially and family-wise trying to look like a dude if I risk lowering my attractiveness and alienating myself from the lesbian community. The thought of being seen as a straight dude is terrifying.
But then the dysphoria comes back and I obsessively look at trans stuff online and fantasize about transition. I feel intensely jealous of transgender men who seem so happy with their transitions. I want to look more masculine, but I don't know if I want it badly enough to risk my health, relationships, and appearance. I don't know if I'm a trans guy in denial, a female, or a butch lesbian who fantasizes about being a dude because I have depression and have invented a hot, badass male version of myself that I imagine when I feel like shit. I have cyclothymia, and I want to break the cycle because it's been going on for 10 years — pain and indecision. I feel stuck and unable to move forward. The trans subreddits just tell me to transition, and the gender-critical people seem biased too, so I came here looking for support and input.
A post about health complications on T actually snapped me out of my most recent trans obsession. I already hate my body parts so much, and the thought of that kind of health complication made me lose sleep — it was terrifying enough to make me not want to go on T. But I've thought and dreamed about transition for so long that I have no idea how to conceptualize myself without it.
I've tried cultivating a more masculine, muscular body as an alternative. I fell off the horse a bit and lost a good deal of the muscle mass I'd worked hard to build. When my depression gets bad, I can't eat much and don't work out, so I lose mass and feel worse about myself. I know I need to go back to it because I felt much better when I was active and had more muscle, and I follow some inspiring butch lifters on Instagram for motivation.
I have dated women, and my dysphoria lets up when I'm in a relationship. It's been a very long time since I've had a functional relationship, and my mental health issues have made dating hard. I sometimes wonder if going on T would cure my depression.
I relate to being super isolated as a teen and turning to the internet, especially art communities. For me that was pre-Tumblr — I'm nearly 30 — so I was mostly on art forums and DeviantArt, where trans wasn't really a thing yet in the online art world. By the time I went to art school, Tumblr had started getting big. I've known a handful of trans guys in real life, all of whom I believe transition was the right decision for their lives. They don't necessarily look more or less attractive now, just like average dudes, and 3 out of 3 still struggle with mental illness. I remember feeling jealous of their changes when they were transitioning, but not as intensely as I feel toward trans guys online who seem to have experienced a massive glow-up and spike in happiness and confidence. It's possible I'm just deceived by the way those guys present themselves online, only showing the good parts.
I'm trying to get my mind out of 'trans world' — I'm going to stay with my chill hippie straight couple friends for a few days.