These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a desisted woman who identified as agender/nonbinary for about 7 years in my 30s, moved a thousand miles away, cut my hair, and went by a neutral nickname — but never took hormones or had any surgeries. What made me desist was starting to pass as nonbinary and realizing that confusing other people about my gender didn't reduce my own confusion, plus Internal Family Systems therapy that helped me see my male and robotic 'managers' were protective parts, not my core Self. My gender confusion and my so-called autistic traits both stemmed from severe early childhood sexual abuse by my narcissistic father, and trauma therapy has resolved most of them. I've gone back to my original feminine name, grown my hair out, lost over 50 pounds, and I'm now at peace identifying as a straight, outdoorsy cis woman in my late 30s. I have no regrets about never medicalizing and advocate strongly against irreversible interventions for all but the most extreme, life-threatening dysphoria.
Full story
I was born female. As a young child I had no sense of gender at all — I was bewildered when I started school and there were boys' and girls' bathrooms, and I genuinely didn't know where they expected me to pee. I assumed I must be a boy because I was clearly more like the boys than the girls, and I thought I was simply waiting for my penis to grow in until my baby brother was born when I was about 5. I was also told by others that I was a girl, but I assumed they were wrong. My parents put me in skirts and wouldn't cut my hair short, but they never explicitly told me I was a girl. I resented the frilly dresses, especially matching ones with my younger sister, and loved looking boyish in mirrors.
I was molested by my father as an infant — before I was verbal — and I remember it vividly. He is a narcissist, and I look like a female version of him. There was also medical neglect and other abuse; food and hunger were weaponized against me. I was verbal incredibly early (100 words correctly by my first birthday), which is why I have these early memories. Around age 10, my parents forced spike earrings through my earlobes against my explicit rejection to make me 'look more like a girl'; the holes never closed and I resented them for 25+ years until I realized I was rejecting what was done to me, not womanhood itself.
As a tween I went hard into being a tomboy. In my later teens I dressed in flattering-but-not-cutesy feminine clothes to avoid attracting attention, particularly from my father. In my early 20s I dated a man with very traditionalist views and, having no identity of my own, convinced myself waist-length hair and floor-length skirts were my vibe. I was always attracted to men and never to women, but people constantly assumed I was a lesbian because I was gender-nonconforming — playing ice hockey, preferring men's clothes and short hair. That got in my head and I concluded I must be a gay *man*, since I clearly wasn't a gay woman. I felt I wasn't 'woman' enough for straight men nor 'man' enough for gay men.
I first heard the terms 'nonbinary' and 'agender' in my late 20s and it was a lightbulb moment. In my early 30s, I moved a thousand miles away, cut my hair short (3 inches on top, tapering from 0.5 inch at the back), and started introducing myself to everyone by a neutral nickname loosely derived from my given name. I worked in a privacy-related field where going by non-legal names was common, so I never legally changed mine. I identified as agender for about 7 years. I never used hormones, never had any surgeries, never even asked anyone to use specific pronouns — I preferred people use whatever they'd remember and draw as little attention to my gender as possible. I was read as an obvious AFAB nonbinary person; sensory issues kept me from binding my D-cup breasts. At one point I owned six identical short-sleeve v-neck t-shirts in the same color and wore only those for a year, including to my sister's funeral.
What made me desist was that I started passing as nonbinary — strangers defaulted to they/them — and it made me feel worse, not better. I thought I wanted other people to be as confused about my gender as I was about myself, but their confusion didn't reduce mine. Around the same time I found Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy. IFS taught me that my psyche is made of 'parts' — exiles carrying burdens, managers protecting them, firefighters reacting — and a core Self. Most of my life, a robotic manager part and a male manager part ran my life, protecting an exiled little girl who was abused as a baby. I thought those features — being robotic, genderless, an 'it' rather than a 'he' or 'she' — were the real me, and professionals agreed I was agender and autistic. As I did the trauma work and those parts stepped back, I realized I am a woman at my core. The soul and body can't be mismatched; we are ensouled bodies, one thing, not two.
I began desisting around 2022-2023. I started growing my hair out (it's now nearly shoulder-length, styled with a round brush to flip outward), buying from the women's section (still mostly flannels, sweaters, Patagonia/LL Bean — normal for northern New England where I live), and wearing small dot earrings I bought myself. About 7 months before my July 2023 post I started telling people my nickname was a nickname, and about a year before that post I decided to go back to my original feminine given name. The turning point for reclaiming it was a friend asking if he could keep calling me by my baptismal name — I realized the name belonged to me for more reasons than my father's giving it to me, and I switched back on the 30th anniversary of my baptism. My estranged father still calls me by the name I abandoned, which I find satisfying. My friends mostly still get it wrong occasionally; they apologize and move on.
I've never been on testosterone. I did take estradiol patches for about two months for a self-generated hormone imbalance (not transition-related) — it gave me blinding headaches and made my hormonal migraines much worse, so I quit. I have IBD and need the bathroom frequently, which is one reason I can't afford to be misread in public. I have a congenital spinal condition that a Pierce-school chiropractor has helped manage. I have a family history of breast cancer (my mother had a double mastectomy for cancer in November 2024, her second unrelated cancer), so I'm told to keep up mammograms. My younger sister died suddenly at 29 of catastrophic heart failure about 7 years ago; she had been 8 months pregnant.
I've done a lot of physical work since desisting: I lost over 50 pounds (from class II obesity, BMI 37, down to about 29 — 20% of my body weight) working with a doctor and dietitian, because I'd been hiding my body inside layers of fat so people wouldn't see me. I now exercise every day, having started with 2-minute sessions on the FitOn app and worked up to a stationary bike under my desk. I wore a dress to a wedding for the first time in a decade and tried makeup for the first time since my senior prom. I also discovered naturist (family nudist) camps, which were transformative for me — being naked in a place where nobody cared what my body looked like showed me my body wasn't the problem, so changing it wouldn't have set me free.
I'm in my late 30s (I was 38 in August 2024, so born around 1985-1986), pushing 40, and I live in northern New England. I'm Catholic, converted after attending a Catholic university. I'm straight — only ever attracted to men — and I consider myself a desisted woman who is 'for all appearances just a cis woman,' though I sometimes wonder whether my core experience is still 'queer' in some meaningful sense. I'm currently single and hoping to partner with a man; I'd love to adopt teenagers aging out of foster care. I work in a field connecting people with help and support services, and I was in a lottery for training in Internal Family Systems therapy so I could help others. I've never been evaluated as a child for anything; an adult psychologist's intake screening once found no signs of neurological atypicality. My current therapist keeps insisting I'm autistic, which I dispute — I believe my 'autistic traits' (stimming, sensory overload, flat affect, obsessive interests) were trauma responses that have improved dramatically with therapy, and autism doesn't typically improve with talk therapy. I have no regrets about never medicalizing; I'm deeply grateful to the protective part of me that stopped me, especially watching my mother go through a mastectomy. I'd describe my current state as at peace, still healing, still navigating presentation 'clumsily' sometimes, but fundamentally reconciled with being a woman.