All stories

Non-binary label dropped over logic, not regret

Female · Desisted99
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a desisted woman who identified as non-binary in my teens but never medically transitioned, and I now identify as a masculine/gender-nonconforming woman. I dropped the label after noticing logical flaws in trans rhetoric and what I saw as fetish-driven motivations in some transitioners. I recently became attracted to a right-wing, traditionally masculine man from work and asked the community how other GNC women have fared dating such men. I worry my masculine presentation — which feels authentic, while femininity feels performative and amped up my dysphoric feelings as a teen — may be a poor fit for men who prefer feminine women. I have little dating experience with men and no medical regrets, since I never transitioned.

Full story

I am a woman who was born female. In my teens I identified as non-binary; I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries, no puberty blockers. I eventually dropped the non-binary label because the trans movement stopped making sense to me. My views had continued growing and expanding, and I started to notice the logical flaws in trans rhetoric. I also noticed that a lot of transitioners seemed motivated by fetishes — I hadn't yet heard the terms AGP or autohomoeroticism, but I recognized what they were from observation. From my perspective, it's not rare for people to have fantasies, but building the core of one's identity off them doesn't make sense. For the last few years I've identified as a masculine / gender-nonconforming woman. I have short hair and tend to wear fairly masculine clothes. I'm often read as a lesbian or non-binary. I still style myself in a fairly masculine way and, honestly, I don't feel super comfortable with overly feminine presentations. I can do it if I need to, but it feels performative — like I'm acting or role-playing, and it gets taxing over time. I tried performing femininity a few times as a teen and it amped up my dysphoric feelings. Once I realized that it's okay to be a masculine-presenting woman, my feelings regarding my gender started to normalize. I don't try to overact or be excessively masculine; I just have certain preferences. I've met plenty of men who do not like GNC behavior in women — a lot of men I've met clearly prefer feminine women and dislike butch ones for relationships. I've also seen women change their presentation for a man; if a woman feels good about that it's completely okay, but it would probably be hard for me to do. I think it would be stressful to feel obligated to change style or personality. Recently I met a man through work whom I feel very attracted to. He is fairly right wing, competitive, and traditionally masculine. He owns his own business and his hobbies are aviation and hunting. Some of his friends follow Redpill content on social media, though I haven't talked with him about redpill topics directly. He's always been very friendly and respectful when I've seen him. I posted to the community asking whether other desisted, detrans, or GNC women had tried dating explicitly right-wing men and how that had gone. I don't have much experience dating men, so I really don't know whether my personality will change around a partner; I doubt it, but I suppose anything is possible. I'm aware that most right-wing men seem to prefer traditionally feminine women, and I've wondered whether my masculine presentation would be a difficulty in a relationship — possibly it's a regional thing where I live, but I haven't seen many couples like that. I wanted to hear from others whether that had been an issue for them, since obviously every situation is unique. I have not described any diagnosed mental health conditions, trauma, or adversity in these posts. I have not expressed regret about medical interventions, since I did not undergo any. My concerns are social and relational rather than medical: whether a masculine-presenting woman can date a traditionally masculine, right-wing man without having to perform femininity.