All stories

Transitioned in 2004 — and still butch, still questioning

Female · Detransitioned306
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a desisted, detransitioned female who now lives as a very masculine butch woman, having socially and medically desisted from a past trans identification while still internally relating to those feelings. I was 18 in 2004 and transitioned before the current cultural wave, and I now advocate for critical thinking about transition, especially for children, while still respecting genuinely trans people I know. I've been through abusive relationships, including a recent partner who exploited my masculinity, and I've lost friends over my views but keep a respectful circle. I've found freedom in my masculine female identity, ride motorcycles, and work in therapy toward self-acceptance. I remain critical of rigid gender ideology, pronoun culture, and social media's influence on youth.

Full story

I was born female and I am a very masculine, butch woman. I was 18 in 2004, at a time when trans people were 'very much still mostly unheard of in wider culture.' At some point I identified as trans and lived socially as a man, but I have since socially and medically desisted. As of June 2024 I described myself as 'a masculine female' who is 'in many ways identify[ing] as trans (though socially/medically desisted)' — meaning I no longer transition medically or socially, but I still relate to those feelings internally. I am consistently read as male in public: I get called 'sir' often, which I don't mind and actually expect and am 'happy to occupy that space.' What I dislike is being singled out — well-meaning people asking 'What are your pronouns?' I tell them I don't care about pronouns and to keep calling me she/her because that's what I am, which has led to enriching conversations. I have found 'immense freedom in my masculine presenting female-ness' and try not to add pressure on myself to meet external metrics like wearing makeup I hate. I am drawn to critical thinking about gender transition, especially for children. I believe the current cultural moment is unusually toxic: being heavily influenced during adolescence is age-appropriate, but 'what makes the current trend so toxic is how extreme, short sighted and permanently damaging it is.' I think transition framed as 'The Only Correct Answer™️' is 'so damn harmful particularly for children.' I also think there is a real, older cohort of genuinely trans people — I personally know a trans woman who was my male teacher and came out in her late 50s nearly 20 years ago, 'a truly kind and grounded soul' — and I feel for younger people 'ambushed with social pressure in their youth.' I'm wary of the LGBT 'community' locally because I've learned 'the hard way not to disclose my thoughts on gender' there, fearing I'll 'get skewered,' and I resent being asked my pronouns. I've also lost more friends than I've gained over the last several years, though the people around me now are respectful. I have a complicated romantic history. My most recent ex was 'basically a covert sex addict' who used me 'to fill a role in her trauma-based fantasy,' specifically because I am masculine and identify as trans despite desisting; it was 'an excruciatingly painful and abusive relationship' I am still healing from. The ex before that used me for her abandonment issues because my masculinity was 'convenient and safe.' Another past partner was an abusive narcissist, and I noted that dating with atypical views on trans issues is risky because 'it does seem like only people who have experienced this stuff can really know and empathize.' I have described myself jokingly as a 'mostly gay bisexual' — mostly attracted to women but sometimes 'a puddle of goo around the right men.' I have been in therapy and made real progress; I once shared a moving sketch about my therapy journey and congratulated someone else on therapy progress, noting how hard it is to find support that understands detransition. I've observed that many therapists are instructed to just 'validate the hell out of social/medical measures' rather than understand detransition. I'm philosophically inclined — I think about authenticity, the two-sided conversation in our minds, and try to hold a '30,000 foot view' without attaching to a specific outcome, telling others (and myself) that 'I am not my feelings. I am not my thoughts. I am.' I also ride motorcycles, currently borrowing an older, heavy V Star 1100 that is comfortable for my height but very heavy, and I'm still a beginner rider. I'm critical of hyper-identity-obsessed social justice culture, mocking people who insist on labeling everyone ('pan-romantic Demi-transgendered rainbow unicorn') and who reduce personality to pride flags. I also blame mobile, data-driven social media for worsening youth mental health, recommending Jonathan Haidt's work. Overall I'm supportive of people finding peace with their bodies and skeptical of rigid rules and shame, encouraging others to stop making up arbitrary rules for themselves and to approach gender with 'tolerance of ambiguity.'