All stories

Five years of waffling over testosterone — and therapy instead

Female · Desisted77
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I socially transitioned as FTM about five years ago, waffled over testosterone the whole time, decided against it, and now identify as non-binary while being fine with she/her pronouns. I was dysphoric and no longer am, largely thanks to regular therapy that helped me separate my insecurities from what testosterone would actually change. I am bisexual and have a supportive partner. I have not had any medical transition interventions and do not describe any regret about hormones or surgery.

Full story

I came out and socially transitioned as FTM about five years before I wrote this, around 2017, and I waffled over hormone therapy for that entire stretch before ultimately deciding against it. I never started testosterone. I identified as non-binary by early 2022, though I wasn't offended by she/her pronouns, and I described myself as bisexual. What moved me away from medical transition was therapy — not just gender therapy, but regular therapy focused on my insecurities. My therapist plainly listed all of my insecurities and told me they would not change by taking testosterone. She walked me through what would realistically happen: my voice would drop some, I would grow a beard, and I would be perceived as a man, albeit a short feminine one. She had me close my eyes and imagine myself with those realistic changes — imagine feeling my beard — and she emphasized the permanence of it. Some people are excited by that prospect; I was not. That was the litmus test that worked for me. I told a parent asking about their child's timeline that I'd have the child have frank conversations with their regular therapist in addition to a gender therapist, and I laid out the impossible bind the parent was in: if you keep them from the medicine and they still want it in 5 or 10 years, you'll always be the roadblock; if you allow it and they regret it, they'll ask why you let them. I advised getting a wide variety of perspectives, including from people who transitioned early who both did and did not regret it, and weighing those without bias. I also told someone considering a lower dose of estrogen that it's still making changes to your body, just over a longer time frame, and that without top surgery breasts are permanent — and that in the US it would mean you can't go topless anymore. I said I wouldn't recommend a lower dose unless you're 100% certain, and that you're looking at the same changes as a high dose, just slower. I was matter-of-fact that it's OK to not have everything figured out, that it's normal to be envious of other people's primary and secondary sex characteristics, and that you don't need to slap a label on the man/NB thing — just roll with whatever pronouns make you most comfortable, and your comfort level can change over time. On dysphoria, I said plainly that I was dysphoric and no longer am. On looks and internalized misogyny, I told someone that the prettier you are, the better people treat you and the easier you navigate the world — objectively life is harder as an average or unattractive person. I described my own arc: I was a young pretty girl, then a young average guy, then a 'semi young, semi unattractive woman' because I stopped caring — no shaving, short hair, no fucks about fashion. I told them the hard truth that even if they stayed a woman they wouldn't be pretty forever, and asked whether they'd rather be an scrungly old man or an scrungly old woman. I named what I saw as internalized misogyny — that a woman's sexual orientation doesn't define how 'genuine' she is — and suggested therapy, not just gender therapy but regular therapy for insecurity as well. I was skeptical of some online gender discourse, warning someone to avoid tumblr ('these are some of the less wild takes that I've seen'), and I joked that a certain practice 'is called hypergymnasia and neither I nor your doctor would recommend it.' On pronouns, I said I'd like to move away from a system where we insist on knowing what genitals someone has by the pronouns we use for them, and that using they/them is my way of making progress toward that. I was accepting of my partner throughout: he was bisexual like me, and when I broached being non-binary with him he was more than accepting, saying he'd love me no matter what. I don't describe surgeries, hospitalizations, or suicidal ideation anywhere in this material. I don't describe my family's reaction, my current relationship status beyond the partner I mentioned, my education or career, or any formal advocacy work. I don't describe my sexual orientation before transition or any pornography use. I don't describe trauma, abuse, assault, bullying, or family dysfunction. I don't describe autism, ADHD, or other neurodivergence. I don't describe fertility concerns or any ongoing medical needs. I don't describe a specific regret about hormones or surgery, since I never medically transitioned — my decision not to start testosterone was deliberate and, as far as this material shows, not a source of anguish.