All stories

Gender nonconformity mistaken for a new identity

Female · Desisted715
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned person who previously identified as agender because I didn't conform to male or female gender roles. I now view gender identity issues through a psychological lens, suggesting links to dissociation and even psychotic-spectrum conditions like schizophrenia. I actively support others detransitioning and share critical commentary about pediatric transition, including whistleblower testimony about "saving trans kids." I have been blunt and politically incorrect in these spaces, sometimes drawing bans for my language. I have not detailed specific medical interventions or ages in this material.

Full story

I have been active in detrans spaces since at least the spring of 2022, and my posts and comments over that period sketch out where my head has been. Early on, in April 2022, I was already thinking about links between serious mental health conditions and gender identity — I suggested that schizophrenia can cause dissociative identity disorder, which can in turn cause gender identity issues. That framing matters to me because I've come to see gender identity as something that can be tangled up with other psychological processes rather than a fixed, innate thing. By September 2022 I described my own history plainly: "i was agender. i didn't conform to male or female gender roles." That's how I understood myself — not fitting into either role, and eventually adopting an agender identity. I've also shared some of the stranger psychological material I've dealt with: in June 2022 I recounted a disturbing dream in which someone ripped my genitals out "through inside my ass" and I chased them until I got them back, saying it made me "think deep thoughts about being agendered." I noted the figure in the dream wasn't me but an androgynous young person in a large cowl covering past their nose. Dreams like that, plus my broader interest in dissociation and identity disruption, suggest to me that my sense of my own body and gender was never straightforward. On the community side, I've been encouraging and blunt with others. In May 2022 I wished someone "good luck on your detransition," and in December 2022 I offered a simple "good job" to someone's update. I've also been willing to say hard things: a comment of mine — "it was not politically correct to keep it real with you" — resonated widely, scoring 64. I don't shy away from unpopular positions. My concerns about the medical and cultural treatment of gender issues have grown more explicit over time. In February 2023 I shared a piece titled "I Thought I Was Saving Trans Kids. Now I'm Blowing the Whistle," which got a large response (528 score) — clearly I want that kind of whistleblower testimony about pediatric transition to circulate. Around the same period I got banned from another community for using the word "groomer," and I made a characteristically dry remark that "cisgender just means normal, right." I've also commented on news events involving violence, saying in March 2023 that "we won't know the motivation until they release the manifesto," and in April 2023 I posted a terse "don't do it" — apparently trying to talk someone out of something harmful. As for my own transition and detransition timeline, I haven't laid out specific ages, dates, medical interventions, or surgeries in the material I've posted here. What I have made clear is that I once identified as agender, that I'm now on the detransition side of things, and that I'm skeptical of how gender identity is framed and treated — especially for kids. I've also shown an interest in dissociative and possibly psychotic-spectrum explanations for gender confusion, which suggests I view my own experience through a lens of psychological complexity rather than a simple born-in-the-wrong-body narrative.