These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I identified as FTM for four years, took testosterone injections for about a year starting around age 16, and stopped in early March 2020 at age 17 without having had any surgeries. I came to believe I had confused dysphoria with a long-standing unhappiness with my body and poor body image, and I began working on accepting myself, though I still experienced lingering dysphoria and envy of a male chest. I felt my doctors failed to adequately inform me about testosterone's risks, including fertility effects and atrophy. I remain supportive of trans people generally while believing transition was not right for me. I currently identify as a detransitioning female, still questioning (self-labeled 'FtMt?'), and I did not report suicidal ideation or self-harm.
Full story
I was 17 when I started heavily questioning my transition, about a year into testosterone injections and after four years of binding my chest. I had identified as FTM for four years total, with testosterone injections in the last year and no surgeries. I'd been off testosterone since early March 2020.
I've never been happy with my body my entire life — I've always wanted something different, regardless of what gender I thought I was. My HRT doctor had told me my breasts would 'pancake' from testosterone, meaning the flattening of the breast tissue, which makes binding easier but I wasn't sure that was what I wanted anymore. My chest was incredibly flat and low, with my nipples way below my breast line. I was worried my post-T chest would never look any different. I looked into breast lifts but worried they don't last long, especially if I ended up binding again. I hated the way my chest looked and did not want top surgery — I thought if I ever got it I would regret it someday. I loathed the idea of breast implants and would never get them. I wondered if exercise focusing on my chest would help, or if I could start taking estrogen to regain breast tissue like MtF people do.
I eventually got to the point where I told myself, 'Yes, if I detransition I will be okay and I am not a freak,' and let myself think about the possibilities detransition might bring. But it felt like I had dysphoria on both sides — I felt like I wanted to be both male and female and nothing at all all at the same time. I knew that if I transitioned I would never truly feel male or be seen as truly male by the world. I wished so badly I had been born male, but I didn't hate my female body anymore. I experienced what I described as possibly penis envy and envy of the freedom males have to take off their shirt, and I found myself envious of post-top surgery photos and the male chest in general, yearning for it. I concluded there was no real way to change my sex and that upset me. I asked others how they coped with dysphoria after detransitioning, worried it was something I'd have to live with for the rest of my life.
Looking back, I realized I had confused dysphoria with just wanting to look different, possibly connected to eating disorder tendencies and a 'real shit body image.' I wished I had gotten therapy for my other mental health issues before transitioning. I wanted to start therapy once I began questioning, and my sister, who was in college studying to become a psychologist, was someone I planned to ask for guidance.
As a minor on HRT, I felt my doctors told me some of the bad side effects — pimples, vaginal atrophy (they only covered vaginal wall thinning and dryness) — but didn't tell me about worse possibilities, like what happened to Buck Angel with his atrophy. I had no idea about the effect testosterone had on fertility until I made a post on r/ftm months earlier, when I still identified that way, asking about testosterone and its effects on fertility. I felt they should have done more research before releasing HRT to the public.
I didn't think I was ever in a cult and never considered anything trans related a cult mentality, except for places like r/egg. The transgender support group I used to go to (and still kind of do) was super supportive of me and the idea of detransitioning. No actual trans person I'd met in real life tried to convince me to stay or be trans — they told me to do what makes me happy. I believed trans people should be monitored better when taking HRT for safety purposes.
I was working on accepting myself and my body, keeping in mind that I am more than just my gender. I could be masculine, feminine or whatever — strong, intelligent, like a cool character I saw on TV and idolized. Gender did not matter to me anymore, though it used to. I still supported trans people fully — I found out transition was not right for me but that did not fill me with hate. I would fully support any current or future trans people in my life because I don't care about what someone identifies as; if it makes them happy that's what matters, and if it turns out it doesn't, I'd support them through that too. I also counseled a sibling of another poster to support their transitioning sibling, saying family is more important than views on gender identity.
At the time of these posts I was still questioning and had not fully settled on a final identity — I labeled myself 'FtMt?' and was working toward accepting myself as female while dealing with lingering dysphoria.