All stories

Three years on estrogen, then a job and a girlfriend

Male · DetransitionedFirst dysphoria 8 → Transition 26254
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned man who identified as trans at 26 and took estrogen and spironolactone for about 3 years before stopping, roughly around the time I got a high-paying job and started dating a girlfriend who knew me as a man. I believe my OCD and mental health struggles drove my desire to be a woman, and I credit work, the gym, and building a real life with curing my trans identification. I still have small A-cup breasts I manage without surgery, and my testosterone and erectile function recovered only partially (about 80% of pre-HRT) with possible permanent hormonal damage. I experience PTSD-like flashbacks and shame about my transition but have found peace through acceptance, core values, and my relationship. I am now critical of medical transition for others and advocate for stricter screening, while still occasionally experiencing the wish to be a woman alongside full acceptance that it is impossible.

Full story

I was born male and started identifying as trans at 26, during my final year of college. Looking back, I had intrusive thoughts about wanting to be a woman since I was around 8 years old, and that obsession would come and go in intensity throughout my life. At the time I started transitioning I was basically an alcoholic and drug abuser, drinking every day and constantly obsessing over being a woman. Despite that internal turmoil, on the outside I had what many would consider a very good life: good grades, no trouble, lots of friends, a college degree, a loving family with no abuse, success in sports, plenty of girlfriends, and I was a leader among other men. I was 6'1", an athlete, and generally very capable. I started HRT (estradiol and spironolactone) and was on it for about 3 years (in another comment I say 3.5 years). During my time presenting as trans, I very rarely dressed like a cis woman - more like a gay non-binary person with earrings and maybe a little eyeliner, a "they/them" style, because dressing fully as a woman made me feel like a freak and I felt people were visibly weird around me. I got small breasts, about an A cup, from the hormones. For the first 2.5 years of transitioning I worked as a bartender after college - a drunken deadbeat lifestyle, having gay sex and dating other trans people. I never had surgeries - I was too poor and too scared - so all I did was take the pills. Several things moved me toward detransition. My time around the trans community turned me off; I felt many of the trans people I met were deeply mentally ill, struggling careers and finances, had severe family issues, or were very autistic and antisocial, and I didn't relate to that. I was also bothered by trans ideology even while identifying as trans - as an athlete I thought it was absurd that there was a debate about trans women competing against biological women; I dominated D1 women's volleyball players and beat my sister's D1 basketball-playing girlfriend 1-on-1 while on hormones. I never corrected anyone who misgendered me because I knew I looked like a man. The real breaking point was getting a new, much higher-paying job where I went stealth - I showed up to the interview in a suit, no earrings or makeup, hair in a man bun, with some facial hair grown out, and passed easily as a cis man even after 3 years of HRT. I was promoted to senior manager within 9 months. Then I met a girl at the company who only knew me as a man; when I told her about being trans and on hormones, she didn't mind and actually encouraged me to be more feminine, but by that point I was just over being trans. Being with her made me feel comfortable as a man; I saw a future with her, a family, a normal life. I realized I was terrible at being a woman and felt like a freak and an invader of female spaces. I also realized being trans would hinder my career ambitions - I'd never be taken seriously in business as a trans person. I stopped HRT about a year into dating her. In another account I describe how I "naturally detransitioned without thinking much about it" - I realized one day I hadn't been trying to be the opposite sex for months despite still taking E daily, so I threw the bottle out. That realization came after I lost my job to COVID, got a low-level manager job at a small retailer, and poured myself into work - I was onsite 28 days straight one month, got promoted to senior manager of the entire site within a year, and quadrupled my salary. I just became engaged in real life and my natural essence showed through. After stopping E (about 2 months off at first check-in), I was worried my testosterone wasn't returning. My sex drive hadn't increased much from pre-HRT levels, morning erections were more frequent but not very strong and didn't happen every morning, and body hair regrowth was minimal - only a small amount of chest hair returned between my breasts, while I remained hairless on my back, upper arms, stomach, and butt cheeks (pre-HRT I had hair all over). About 1.5 years off E, I reported that most improvement in erectile function plateaued within 3-6 months of stopping. My erections were about 80% of pre-E quality; I could only stay at max hardness for 3-5 minutes; it takes more effort to orgasm during intercourse (though masturbation still takes about 1 minute); spontaneous erections and morning wood are rarer and less intense; libido improved but never fully returned. I wanted to get my T levels checked and said I'd probably try TRT if I had low T, wondering if 3 years of E caused permanent damage to my testosterone production. I still have small breasts ("lil nubs") that I've chosen not to have surgically removed - I build muscle, stay lean, keep chest hair, and avoid skin-tight clothing, and if I'm shirtless I just look like I have a little gynecomastia. I have no concern being shirtless at a public pool. Mentally, I have a lot of PTSD from my time as "trans" - it's a lot to unpack. I get flashbacks while driving of myself as trans or of cringe things I did, I think about friends I lost when I first came out, and how I forced friends and family into my charade and brought strife into their lives. Snapchat memories pop up reminding me of mistakes. I still feel shame sometimes looking at my small breasts, and strangely I still feel like I want to be a woman - but now I fully accept that's impossible, which brings a kind of peace. I believe my OCD is the main cause of my desire to become the other gender, and I now think being "trans" is really a variety of mental illnesses/neurodivergence that people self-diagnose into transgenderism. I also struggled with crippling anxiety during my trans years - so bad I couldn't even drive - and was an alcoholic living like a manchild. What helped me most was therapy in the informal sense of throwing myself into work, going to the gym (I recommend lifting weights 5-6 days a week), building skills, and focusing outward rather than inward. I tell people that just because you feel a certain way doesn't mean you should act on it, that suffering is normal, and that the way you look is the least important thing in life. My core values now are being kind, giving and receiving love, enjoying nature and hobbies, building physical strength and skill, building wealth, and working toward goals. I have a girlfriend and see a future with family and kids. I'm critical of transition for others - I think doctors should say no more often, that there should be intense screening and waiting periods before any irreversible surgery, and that "transphobia" is a term used to gaslight people thinking objectively. I don't do formal advocacy but I give blunt advice to detransitioning males: go to the gym, get a job, grind, build a life. Overall my quality of life is much better than during my transition, though the scars and flashbacks remain.