All stories

Two years as a trans man, no hormones, and no dysphoria

Female · DesistedSocial transition 19 → Desistance 211.6K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a desisted woman who privately identified as a trans man and socially transitioned for almost two years (from mid-2018, age 19) but never took hormones or had surgery, and I desisted over about a year after the pandemic began. I now understand my transition was a coping mechanism for childhood sexual trauma and early puberty sexualization, compounded by a longstanding disconnect from femininity — I never actually had gender dysphoria. In late 2021/early 2022 I became distressed while my partner suddenly pursued a trans identity with what I saw as red flags, at one point writing 'If I'm not okay, I promise I won't hurt myself.' I advocate caution about medical transition, criticize gender euphoria as a transition criterion, and believe detransition/desistance rates are under-reported.

Full story

I was born female and grew up as a tomboy who loved sports and outdoor activities, playing with Hot Wheels and Transformers as well as Bratz Dolls and Polly Pocket. I hit puberty early, at age 8, and developed quickly; by 11 I was first sexualized and groped, and from then on I was increasingly seen and treated as an object by many people. I grew up thinking that kind of attention was normal. By 15 I had body dysmorphia and was in therapy for depression and anxiety. I had felt disconnected from what it meant to be a woman since childhood, and combined with the trauma and sexual harassment, that disconnect led me to question my gender identity. In mid-2018, at 19, I privately identified as a trans man and began socially transitioning under people's noses. I cut my hair as short as it would go, stole my boyfriend's baggy clothes, stopped wearing makeup, and bound my chest. Because I have soft, feminine features, neither my partner (who I practically lived with) nor my friend group realized what was happening — they assumed I was just experimenting with androgyny. I lived this way for almost two years, and they were some of the most painful years of my life. Strangely, I never actually experienced gender dysphoria and I didn't even like he/him pronouns, yet I still yearned to go on testosterone. I was a few months away from consulting a gender therapist to get on T, which I now believe would have been one of the biggest mistakes of my life. I was in a large LGBTQ+-oriented college friend group (ages roughly 19–24) that included two trans men and one trans woman. One trans man, who started T, became what I described as a raging asshole, got physically violent over a minor disagreement about trans athletes, and started gatekeeping all discussion of trans issues. I refused to enable his behavior and left the group (they claim they kicked me out); last I heard they view me as a transphobe. Another friend in that circle had been on T, got sick from it, stopped, and detransitioned to identify as a cis woman — but even witnessing that firsthand wasn't enough to sway my own urge to medically transition. I was 21 when the pandemic hit, and being sent home from college was a blessing in disguise. I didn't leave my house for almost three months. Being at home forced me to confront my mental health; I got into contact with a counselor, cleaned out my room and found my old makeup and clothes, let my hair grow out, stopped binding, and got fitted for a proper sports bra. I was slowly desisting without realizing it. One evening looking in the mirror I realized I liked my appearance, though I was still disconnected from what it meant to feel like a woman. It took about a full year to desist. During that time I realized I was 'okay' with she/her pronouns and had to confront a hard truth: I had been transitioning as a coping mechanism for my trauma. When I presented androgynous, men stopped approaching and sexualizing me, and that felt safe. I also realized I had neither gender dysphoria nor gender euphoria. I refer to myself as a desister rather than a detransitioner because I never medically transitioned. I shared my story anonymously once before, about two months prior to my main post, and was told by trans men and women alike that I was just a 'trans man in denial' — my story was questioned because I hadn't actually gone on T and had kept everything quiet. Some people DM'd me and made it worse, so I deleted my original account. I finally told my partner of four years about all of it in December 2021, which was a relief. In late 2021 and early 2022, my own partner began showing what I saw as red flags around a sudden trans identity: they were misgendered once over the phone and within less than a month of contemplating she/her pronouns wanted to revolve their whole identity around those pronouns, their story about how long they'd felt this way kept changing, and they refused to discuss any concerns, telling me 'I already know what you're gonna say' and lecturing me. I believe they were radicalized by the online trans community on TikTok and Twitter, and that their ADHD (impulsivity and hyper-fixations) made them fixate on gender identity. That period put me at my lowest of lows — my brain felt foggy, I couldn't sleep, and I told the community plainly: 'If I'm not okay, I promise I won't hurt myself.' I reached out to others for advice and considered taking a few days to myself. I now think gender euphoria does more harm than good as a criterion for transition, that detransition statistics are massively under-reported because detransitioners are silenced and demonized, and that red flags include obsession with gender identity, defensiveness about questions, and treating medical transition as the only path to using different pronouns. I've advised parents to let kids be kids, be careful with pronouns, rule out other mental health conditions before assuming gender dysphoria, and consult a general counselor rather than a gender-specialist therapist first. I also passed along lessons from detransitioners: if you're in doubt, stop and re-evaluate; research how HRT affects pre-existing conditions (my acquaintance had to stop T because of a heart/cardiovascular condition and detransitioned about six months later); and seek professional help for unresolved trauma before making permanent changes. I've been active in this community sharing my story so others might see where I'm coming from, since I had no one in my personal life who had desisted or detransitioned.