All stories

Told trans kids kill themselves at 15 — then stopped believing

Female · Desisted146
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned female who socially transitioned as a cautious teen, adopting a male social identity but never going further medically. I was deeply harmed by being told that trans kids kill themselves, which made me believe that not getting my way about pronouns and names would lead to suicide, and I was quite depressed as a result. I now find the way trans communities discuss suicide sickening and fear for children being raised in what I call gender dogma. I desisted and hold a critical view of transition, believing there is no essential "true" trans and that I was a believer who is no longer one. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm since detransitioning.

Full story

I was told, as a young person, that trans kids kill themselves, and that message got inside my head: I came to believe that being suicidal was what would happen if I didn't get my way about pronouns and my name. So I was quite depressed, because I thought that not "being my true self" — putting myself at risk for severe mental and physical health issues — was the end of the world, a great injustice forced upon me, an innocent trans man. I now find the way trans communities talk about suicide sickening and disgusting: it flies in the face of everything suicide researchers tell us NOT to do when discussing suicide, it's borderline martyrdom, and it glorifies suicide for impressionable people like children. This still haunts me and I fear for kids. I describe myself as having been always too cautious as a teen and never strayed further than adopting a male social identity, for worry of consequences — so I never went on hormones or had surgery as far as I've said. I worry about kids out there getting major cosmetic surgery because they've developed complexes in which, if they don't get what they want, the only option is suicide; my heart breaks for them because I know their pain. I believe there is no essential "true" trans — in my view those who are trans are simply those who have transitioned or begun transition, undertaking a material or social process, not people with some essential trans quality. I have described myself as having desisted, and I told another person that they sound a bit like me when I first desisted. I read a 16-year-old's post and told them that of course they have identity issues at 16, that growing into a woman (or rather, being socially classified as a woman) is a traumatic experience thanks to the way the world treats women, and that nobody on the internet can answer their questions but they should keep digging. I also told someone that wanting to be a woman again in order to wear dresses and makeup says a lot about why they transitioned in the first place — a conflation of gender roles with sex. I believe detransitioners are hated "because we were in the thick of gender ideology, we were believers, and now we aren't." I've said "we are failing children" and that we are already seeing sky-high rates of teen suicide, asking how many more kids will irreversibly alter their bodies or die before people stray from the gender dogma. I have not described any therapy, medical intervention, diagnosis, family situation, sexuality, or specific regret beyond the lost time and the belief that I was harmed by the ideology I once believed in.