All stories

A gender-critical ally since 2019, never a detransitioner

Female · Desisted141
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a gender-critical woman, not a detransitioned person, who has commented in detrans spaces since 2019 while explicitly stating it is "not my place" to participate directly. I critique transition as rooted in transhumanist ideology and internalized misogyny, and I have explored therapeutic alternatives like psychodynamic therapy and a modified exposure therapy approach that I say worked for me. I view autogynephilia as a trauma-based fetish and have advised moderation rather than transition. I am active in warning detrans communities about platform censorship and in cautioning gender-critical circles against cult-like behavior.

Full story

I have been a regular commenter in detrans spaces since at least 2019, and my contributions make clear that I am gender-critical rather than detransitioned myself. I have explicitly written that I avoid participating in the detrans subreddit directly because, in my words, "it's not my place," and I have argued that other gender-critical people should likewise stay out and post in more suitable subreddits instead. My engagement is largely analytical and argumentative. I have critiqued the medical and ideological framing of transition, describing what I see as "a combination of transhumanist ideology and objectification of women," arguing that transhumanism promotes unrealistic ideas about surgery and that breasts are culturally treated as "extra objects that are not included with the basic human model." I have also raised the question of how one would regulate accusations of transphobia when a person might genuinely benefit from transition, and what doctors could do to make poor outcomes less likely in the future. I have engaged seriously with therapeutic alternatives to transition. When someone proposed exposure therapy for gender dysphoria, I was skeptical that it would work as described, comparing it to gay conversion therapy, but I also developed the idea further: reframing gender dysphoria as a kind of masculinity/femininity phobia and using exposure therapy not to force someone into a gender role but to desensitize them and to validate their emotional reactions to patriarchal stereotypes. I noted that I had done something similar myself and that it worked for me, while acknowledging others would have to weigh in on whether dysphoria is truly analogous to a phobia. I also suggested that a massive overhaul of internalized misogyny combined with psychodynamic therapy might help. I have commented on autogynephilia, describing it bluntly as "not a coping mechanism, that's a fetish that's a result of trauma," and I have advised someone that moderation, "no fap," or simply accepting a fetish without acting on it excessively could spare them from transitioning "for a thrill" - comparing it to eating chocolate cake in moderation rather than to the point of needing gastric bypass. I have also engaged with the social and psychological dimensions of transition and detransition. I have asked people what "living life as a guy" means to them, whether they felt included by men, and suggested that rigid categorization of what men and women do could be a feature of Asperger's or OCD. I have observed that identity can become fragile when it depends on group membership, and I have encouraged people to build identity on sturdier foundations rather than relying on gender as a crutch. On community issues, I have been vocal about the vulnerability of detrans spaces to Reddit crackdowns, warning of "a wave of cancellations" and advising people to archive content and find backup platforms. I have also pushed back against cult-like behavior in gender-critical circles, cautioning that encouraging someone to cut off friends over ideological disagreement is itself something "a cult would do."