All stories

Social transition felt wrong — the roles were the problem

Female · Desisted38
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned (or desisted) woman who stopped identifying as trans around July-August 2019 after social transition felt wrong to me. I came to believe my dysphoria was rooted in society forcing gender roles, internalized misogyny, and a gender-based trauma rather than being innate. I still experience occasional waves of wishing I were male, mostly social rather than body dysphoria, and struggle to find women with a gender expression like mine. I have not described any medical transition steps. I do not describe suicidal ideation or self-harm.

Full story

I used to think I was a trans man until about a month before August 2019. For me, the turning point was really when I started social transition — I noticed it wasn't right. I started socially transitioning a while ago and it didn't really feel right. At some point I noticed that the reason I want to be a boy is because it looks to me like boys have it better than girls, not because I'm transgender. When someone asked me why I would have thought I was trans if not for social dysphoria, I described the discomfort as being about gendered things that aren't bodies — for example, your name, your pronouns, your clothes, people calling you lady. I've thought a lot about what causes gender dysphoria. My view is that gender dysphoria sometimes has biological causes (hormones, I don't know), in which case really the only good option is transitioning. And in other cases it's caused by society, trauma or something like that. So either it's nature or nurture. In my case it's the latter — loads of internalized misogyny and a gender based trauma. I think that would be a good solution, I just don't really know how it can be determined what type any individual has. In September 2019 I wrote a post about dysphoria and representation. In the past week or so I'd been feeling more dysphoric again. Before that my dysphoria had pretty much disappeared as soon as I figured out that the reason (in my case) for dysphoria isn't my brain or anything like that but rather society forcing gender roles. I'd been spending a lot of time trying to find other women and girls with a gender expression similar to mine and had a surprisingly hard time. My dysphoria at that moment wasn't really body dysphoria. I just really wished I was male so I could feel normal. My ideal looks were really just some average white boy — I see so much of it online and it makes me really jealous. Why could I find hardly any women who express themselves (gender wise) like me? I just felt so alone and gross. I know I'm not, but it's so tempting to start telling myself I'm transgender again. I pushed back when someone implied I was mutilating myself — I said I'm not mutilating myself and asked what made them think I was doing that. I also said their comment was aimed at me. When asked about attraction, I said plainly that I'm not attracted to them. Another thing I've said is that the inferiority of women is manmade. I don't describe any medical interventions, surgeries, hormones, or puberty blockers anywhere in what I've written. I don't describe my current identity beyond no longer believing I'm trans. I don't describe therapy, medication, diagnoses, family reactions, relationships, or how my mental health has changed over time. I don't describe any suicidal ideation or self-harm. I haven't described any advocacy or activism beyond posting and commenting in this community.