All stories

Years planning to transition — and never once needing to

Female · Desisted681
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned (desisted) straight woman who never accessed HRT or surgery but spent years planning to transition to male before deciding to pursue self-acceptance instead. My dysphoria was rooted in internalized misogyny, gender nonconformity, a masculine face and bone structure, being bullied for my looks, a distant mother who died in my teens, and heavy online/fandom immersion. What helped me desist was therapy (which initially made me more obsessive), a job change into funeral service, real-world connections, fluoxetine for overthinking, and deliberately cutting out transition timelines and trans content. I am now in a long-term relationship with a cis man and identify as a woman, though I still struggle with feeling mismatched in my body, envy of successful transitions, and shame about being perceived. I remain critical of what I see as performative trans/non-binary identification in online art and fandom spaces while supporting people who explore detransition at their own pace.

Full story

I was born female and grew up as a mousey, awkward tomboy in a religious, traditional family that gave me very little autonomy — I wasn't allowed to cut my hair short until I was 15. I grew up working in a male-leaning family business and had a very distant mother who passed away in my teens. From childhood I wanted short hair and to essentially 'roleplay' as a dude because I didn't like how I was treated as a girl; I internalized a lot of misogyny and was bullied by friends and family for not being more feminine, and even got bullied for 'trying to look pretty' when I attempted femininity. I felt like a Barbie doll body with a Ken doll head — boy clothes never fit me right (neckties too long, male hats silly, male-cut jeans awkward), and girl clothes looked bizarre on my masculine face, so it felt like there was no winning. I interpreted this as: I couldn't be a guy because of my body and bone structure, but I also couldn't be an attractive, worth-loving girl for the same reason. My goal was always androgyny rather than full transition — I liked looking boyish, elvish, tomboyish, 'like an alley cat with a cut in its ear.' I spent years researching transition, presenting masculine, and poring over transition timelines, getting envious of people who had the results I wanted (thick beard, thicker brow, longer eyelashes — I especially envied Jamidodger because he had my ideal transition). I was about to come out to friends and family when suddenly almost all the alt women and artists I looked up to came out as some flavor of trans or non-binary (one identifying as fairygender), along with several celebrities. That wave of coming-outs actually helped convince me not to transition — seeing so many people claim trans identity made me jealous that they could do it wholeheartedly while I'd been sitting on it nearly my entire life, and it felt unfair. I also found it helpful reading detrans accounts of people who got their 'perfect' transition results and still detransitioned because it didn't fix the underlying problems. Ultimately I decided to strive for self-acceptance instead of going through with HRT plans. I never came out IRL except to a friend, and I never medically transitioned — I never got HRT. I describe myself as a desisted Ftmtf / straight female desister. What actually moved me toward desisting was a combination of therapy (which honestly made me more obsessive about how I looked and behaved), moving, getting a job with patient and caring people, and eventually medication. I was very online in fandom and artsy circles — introverted, 'failure to launch,' lonely IRL — and I had to deliberately cut out transition timelines, trans subreddits, and trans YouTubers to keep from regressing. Getting my license, a job, and real-life connections — including an emotionally demanding job in funeral service — helped me stop obsessing. Dealing with grief up close was extremely humanizing and humbling. I also started fluoxetine (generic Prozac) after a year-plus of therapy and a crisis where I was 'hopeless and at the end of my rope'; the medication took about a month to work, with initial sleepiness and nausea, but it shut down my overthinking and made a night-and-day difference — I hadn't been that clear-headed my whole adult life. I also worked through a lot of internalized misogyny. I was ashamed of 'the poor woman/girl I made' and every day felt like a walk of shame about how bad at it I was. I thought I had to be a lesbian because everyone assumed I was since childhood, and I felt like I had to lean into a trans/non-binary identity because I 'fit the bill' to my social circle and fighting it made me look guiltier. What helped was connecting with words like 'daughter' and 'sister' (less tainted than she/her for me), seeking out butch/androgynous women to look up to, female comedians, and podcasts run by women, and focusing on style I liked while removing gender from it. I also had a realization about attraction: I'm drawn to masculinity, so I felt more attractive presenting masculine — essentially, 'if I couldn't have a boyfriend, I would become my own boyfriend,' which I've called being a female incel. I was also very into 4chan and anime and saw the 3DPig stuff, and instead of wishing I were a cute anime girl I wished I were a guy so I could opt out of the female rat race. I'm now in a long-term relationship with a straight cis man. I told him early on about my history; he basically said 'you are a woman to me even though you don't conform to society's ideas of femininity,' which at first felt invalidating but was actually challenging my poor self-image. I had to ask him not to make comments about my body (even positive ones) because they trigger old wounds and make me spiral. I still get misgendered because of my short hair, masculine face, A-cup chest, and men's t-shirts, and I was humiliated being singled out for pronoun questions at two different jobs simply because I'm AFAB with short hair. I still struggle with feeling mismatched — short female body with male arms, hands, and face — and I find dresses create too much whiplash, so I stay 24/7 in androgynous Target wear. I worry about whether I'll ever be comfortable in anything other than oversized t-shirts, including at a future wedding. I still envy successful transitions in a 'grass is always greener' way, and I still struggle with feeling inherently wrong or ugly in feminine clothing, but it's improved with avoiding transition content, focusing on style without gender, and medication. I've also dealt with intrusive thoughts about existing and being perceived — I've said I just want to exist without being perceived, and that the act of existing feels distressing. I've been bullied for being awkward and ugly as a kid, and I have a lot of issues with my bone structure that feel unchangeable. I've described feeling like a subclass of human and being 'the unattractive woman in a relationship with a man that out-looks me,' while also recognizing intellectually that this worldview is unhealthy and not how normal people think. I've been critical of how quickly AFAB people in my artsy/fandom circles are coming out as trans or non-binary, of newly-out people asking for online donations, and of what I see as a holier-than-thou attitude among some AFAB creators who identify as anything but female. I've also been frustrated at being asked my pronouns at work purely because of short hair. I've advocated for people to focus on self-acceptance and mental shifts rather than physical change, recommended avoiding 4chan/incel spaces, and encouraged others exploring detransition to go at their own pace. I'm childfree by choice and don't currently plan on having children.