All stories

Estrogen to sign off from being a man

Male · Detransitioned33
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born male, transitioned and took estrogen for an unstated period, and by early 2022 had detransitioned and was living as a man again. I attribute my transition partly to an autistic-like lack of concrete identity, feeling like a nerdy unwanted male, and wanting to sign off from the responsibilities of being a man. Some hormonal changes reversed and some did not — my skin remains unusually smooth, which I noted as a turn-off for some women. I now feel at peace, describing myself as "back to normal" with my "rightful place in society" restored. I am critical of puberty blockers, of porn-driven "femboy" identities, and of how transition is promoted, and I do not discuss mental health diagnoses, therapy, surgery, fertility, or suicidal ideation in these posts.

Full story

I was born male and grew up in a household where I later described myself as having "an extreme lack of concrete identity" and being "some nerdy unwanted male" who didn't feel masculine. I spent a lot of time on 4chan earlier in my life. At some point I transitioned and went on estrogen for a period of time; I don't give exact dates in these posts, but by early 2022 I had detransitioned and was living as a man again. I don't lay out a full timeline, but I describe the aftermath of hormones in concrete terms: some changes reversed and some did not. I wrote that "some of that will not reverse" and that "I look a lot different now, than I did after lots of estrogen. But some of it won't reverse." Specifically, my skin stayed very smooth — a girl I was with kept mentioning how smooth my skin is, and I suspected it's "actually a turn off for a lot of women." I've been advised, and advise others in a similar position, that working out, lowering body fat percentage so bone structure shows through more prominently, and building muscle can help one look more masculine again. On the causes of my own transition, I frame it partly as avoidance: "Its more about signing off from the natural responsibilities of being a man." I also believe that if you deviate from masculine norms, "Just don't expect sex or love" from the people you interact with, even though the culture says "BE YOURSELF!" I think autism or a weak sense of identity can push a nerdy, unwanted, non-masculine male toward hormones and toward identifying with trans porn performers as a way to "feel sexy and get attention." I also think sexual factors matter — I said it's "delusion" when obvious truths are ignored, giving as an example "how sex drive and sexual compulsion can heavily influence transition in males." I've argued that many men feel physically incapable of feeling sexy as a man because male sex standards are "completely crazy and out of this world," while the media only covers female insecurity and Instagram insecurity. I'm critical of how transition is discussed and enabled. I've called the idea that voices in your head are a transition-related concern nonsense: "You are mentally unwell, trans and hormones are the least of your concerns," and noted finasteride can essentially eliminate DHT-driven hair loss. I'm skeptical of puberty blockers, saying I can't imagine how pissed I'd be if I were male, went on blockers at 10, ended up with "some shriveled up dick and weak bones," and then decided I wanted to be a guy — "Would never ever reach my full potential." I've also criticized what I see as a disturbing trend of Gen Z porn addicts identifying as "femboys," describing them as addicted to emasculation porn who develop alternative identities rather than give up porn, and I'm scathing about sex-positive communities that validate extreme porn habits. On street harassment, I recounted that all the negative comments I ever got in Europe were from Arabs in Paris, and in the US from homeless people, "black and white that comment on you. In order to raise themselves up in their own eyes." I said one of the worst things about being trans is that "even the scum of society will feel superiority over you despite you being better than them in countless ways," and that it filled me with rage. Now that I am "back to normal" I feel at peace, "like I have my rightful place in society again. My ego is validated." On dating, I've advised caution about bisexual girls, saying stereotypes come from real observations and that bisexual women tend to lean toward men for long-term relationships, though I added "I am a dude, not a lesbian, so don't listen to me." I've told people not to let relationships give them panic attacks, and argued that women who feel inferior to men are probably only comparing themselves to the top quarter of desirable men, since "80% of guys are literally physically unnattractive to women." I don't discuss mental health diagnoses, therapy, family, fertility, surgeries, or suicidal ideation in these posts. My regret is expressed through relief rather than explicit statements of regret: I feel at peace and restored in my social place now that I've detransitioned, while acknowledging some bodily changes from estrogen are permanent.