All stories

A gender non-conforming girl in the 1980s who never transitioned

Female · Desisted359
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a gender critical, autistic woman who was a very gender non-conforming girl in the 1980s but never identified as trans; I post in detrans communities to support desisters and detransitioners while being clear I am not detrans myself. I have never transitioned, so there is no detransition timeline or regret about medical interventions in my own case. I am critical of the medicalisation of gender non-conforming and autistic children, and I share my own experience of bullying, autism, and seeing the body as an 'avatar' as context for that view. I had my first child at 37 and froze eggs beforehand, and I offer fertility information to detransitioners from that research. I am currently nearing 40 and in a good place, describing myself as putting the finishing touches on my life and feeling great.

Full story

I was a very gender non-conforming girl growing up in the 1980s — often mistaken for a boy — but I never considered myself trans. I was bullied as a child, and I'm autistic, which I say because I recognise the 'wrong planet syndrome' feeling and once held the view that the body is just a 'meat sack' or avatar that could be swapped out; I would have seriously considered a 'brain in a jar connected to a computer' option if it had been offered to me at the wrong point in time. I'm now a gender critical woman, and I post in detrans spaces because I realise how easily I could have been persuaded that I really was or should have been a boy if I had grown up today. I explicitly state I am not detrans — I've never identified as trans — but I come to these communities to support desisters, detransitioners and questioning trans people, and I promise to post nothing that would put their space at risk. I'm now nearing 40 and in the process of putting the finishing touches on my personal 'this is how things should be', and it feels great. I had my first child at 37 and froze some eggs before that, which led me to read a lot about fertility; I've advised a detransitioning person that they can get AMH (Anti-Müllerian Hormone) checked and antral follicles counted via vaginal ultrasound to assess how many eggs remain, while noting there's no way to check egg quality short of fertilising a batch, and that if the eggs survived it's unlikely their DNA was damaged since sperm carries DNA and survives testosterone just fine — while being clear I hold no medical degree. I'm deeply critical of what is being done to gender non-conforming and autistic children today. I've said I could easily have been persuaded I was a boy, and that's why this issue gets to me. I think modern technology and autism can lead people to see their body as an avatar, and that this perception is one factor in the manyfold increase in young transitioners, which can lead to tremendous suffering down the road when you realise you cannot reshape or swap out your body and end up with a body perpetually dependent on drugs and interventions. I believe children should be allowed to experience their body and person as a unity, and that almost all autistic kids are bullied (I was) while today's gender 'woowoo' offers a chance to 'remake yourself'. I've told a questioning autistic person that there is nothing wrong with them, that there are rather masculine women and non-stereotypical men, and that it is exhausting to work against your body or mind — they should work with what they have and build a life that makes them feel good about their male biology and autistic mind. I've also suggested leaving the gender question up in the air while getting physically and mentally healthy, and noted that long-term cardiovascular and other health effects of hormones seem to be downplayed by doctors and activists. I follow the UK developments closely — the lawsuits, the critical BBC report on GIDS — and I've drawn an analogy to the 1960s-80s German push to decriminalise 'non-violent pedophilia', where progressive people and parts of the Green party lobbied for it, arguing the mechanism of looking the other way when children are harmed in order to appear uber progressive is similar (I clarified I did not want to directly compare trans rights activists with pedophiles). I support JK Rowling and thank detrans voices who braved attacks with no resources and next to no support, and I quote Carl Sagan: 'If it can be destroyed by the truth, it deserves to be destroyed by the truth.' I have compassion for any trans person just trying to live their life in peace, but I believe the activists will eventually look back and think it was a big mistake. I've expressed fear for every girl who reminds me of the girl I was, saying that at best some of the brightest biological females of a generation lose years and parts of their health on transitioning, and at worst are lost entirely. I also like deep girl voices and note they contribute to being taken more seriously.