All stories

Three years on estrogen, then the 'transition or die' thinking broke

Male · Detransitioned81
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who lived as a trans woman for years, including about three years on estrogen and spironolactone, before realizing transition had not delivered what I expected and had only added negativity to my life. During transition I experienced severe suicidal ideation driven by 'transition or die' thinking, but that has completely resolved since detransitioning. I credit a trans friend and other key people with helping me see the unrealistic expectations I'd absorbed from online trans communities, which I now view as cult-like. I still deal with some irreversible changes from HRT, including breast tissue, permanently altered skin texture, and lasting facial fat deposition. I am now critical of uncritical cheerleading of transition and believe most MtFs do not pass, despite what online communities claim.

Full story

I was born male and lived for years as a trans woman before detransitioning. My experience of transition was, in hindsight, defined by unrealistic expectations that online trans communities actively fed. I used to believe the majority of before-and-after facial feminization surgery (FFS) pictures showed genuinely passable trans women, because the 'before' looked so masculine to me. But I came to realize FFS did not actually make them pass — they just looked more feminine than before, and were essentially stuck living as visibly trans women. I think the vast majority of MtFs vastly overestimate their ability to pass, telling themselves 'if I just train my voice, if I just get better hair, if I just laser my beard, if I just get FFS' — when in reality most males can do all of that and still not look female. Passing in internet photos or casual interactions is not the same as passing completely as female. I know from personal experience that most of the trans MtFs posting online who appear 'passable' really don't pass and are often quite miserable, living shut-in, insecure lives. I can clock at least 99% of MtFs after interacting with them briefly, partly because I know the differences between male and female skeletons, and partly because humans instinctually gender people. I was on estrogen and spironolactone for about three years. During that time I had the typical changes: emotional shifts around sex (on estrogen, sex felt more about emotions and excitement), breast tissue development, skin changes, and subcutaneous fat deposition in my face that left it permanently puffier than before. My testicles shrank but returned completely to normal size afterward, and I had my sperm tested, which showed normal behavior and vitality. I also found that actual female clothing like dresses or specific female tops never felt comfortable, because they were clearly designed for a body with different hip-to-torso-to-shoulder proportions than I had. Androgynous clothing — jeans, slim shirts, drapey things with more room — was fine. During the throes of transition I experienced very strong suicidal ideation, driven by fatalistic 'transition or die' thinking and the feeling that my goal was unachievable, so life was just distress and pain. What pulled me back from the edge was key people in my life — one trans friend in particular — who opened my eyes to the unrealistic expectations of transitioning and helped me discover that transitioning was not necessary and had only introduced negativity into my life rather than being a path to a better me. Since detransitioning, all that suicidal ideation has been swept away; I no longer care about or desire the previous goal, and life feels full of possibilities again. I am highly critical of online trans communities, which I view as cult-like, with language and beliefs that must not be trespassed — for example the classic cultist framing of 'you are here for a reason, your internal self brought you here.' I have seen too many trans people, especially young transitioners, cheered on by 'peppy' and 'encouraging' community members with artificial, cult-like emotional support, only to end in suicide. I believe that kind of environment fuels unrealistic expectations and a kind of fetishization of suicide. I also think society assigns value based on physical characteristics, and that the average female is only ever going to transition into a low-value man, and vice versa for MtFs — much as extremely short men are often insulted and not taken seriously, which is part of why incomes correlate strongly with height.