All stories

Growing up gay in a Catholic home, transition looked like the exit

Male · Detransitioned1.6K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned male who lived out as MTF for about a year, took blockers for two months at 19, and was on surgery waiting lists but never fully medically transitioned. Growing up gay in a conservative Catholic environment with heavy bullying led me to see transition as an escape from homophobia. Letting go of religion and working through internalised homophobia is what led me to detransition. I now identify as a feminine gay man and find accepting myself as a feminine male liberating. I have engaged with detrans advocacy, including being offered a YouTube interview.

Full story

I grew up in a conservative Catholic household where rigid gender norms were enforced and being gay was demonised. I and my other gay peers were bullied mercilessly for being effeminate. Looking back, I think that hostile environment was a major reason I fell down the trans rabbit hole: I came to see transition as a way to escape the homophobia I was facing, while also giving me an outlet to express myself the way I wanted. In hindsight I view it as a coping mechanism rather than an authentic need. I came out and lived "out" as MTF for around one year. During that time I took puberty blockers for two months at age 19, and I was on waiting lists for surgeries, though I never fully medically transitioned. Despite that, I definitely considered myself detransitioned when I stopped. The turning point for me was letting go of my belief in God. Realising there is nothing "wrong" with being gay, and actively working on my internalised homophobia, was what led me to detransition and has been incredibly liberating. My realisation was essentially that makeup is not gendered and that males can wear mascara too — that transition promotes an impossible dream, when really we should be teaching each other to embrace our sex while also embracing non-conformity. It has been a process coming to terms with the fact that I am a feminine male, but accepting myself for who I am has been nothing but liberating. I now identify as a feminine gay man. I have said publicly that I think effeminate gay men are still the most marginalised by society, even though other prejudices get much more advocacy, and I have suggested this is evidenced by the fact that MTF detransitions are much less prevalent than FTM ones. In 2022 I was offered an interview as a detrans perspective on a medium-sized YouTube channel. I hesitated because I never fully medically transitioned and did not want to talk over the voices of people who did, but I still consider myself definitely detrans. I did not say in the transcript whether I accepted. I have also noted, speaking as a libertarian rather than a liberal, that it angers me when people frame the current transgender trend as a "disease created by the left and secularism," because for me it was the complete opposite — it was the conservative, religious environment that drove me toward transition. At the same time I try to be respectful of other detransitioners' reasons: everyone's experience is valid and I am happy for anyone detransitioning no matter the reason.